We've been on STJ before. They play at a higher level than monument I believe. STJ will play Open division, national and sometimes USA depending on the tournament. I don't think monument plays at the open division ever. So if she's looking to play at a higher level moving forward I would do STJ.

My DD's trying out for a bunch of clubs this weekend and in the off chance that she receives multiple offers, we're trying to rank the clubs in order of priority. We can't decide which club is better between the 2 - St James or Monument so leaning on the collective wisdom of the group to help us decide.

Both their practice locations are close to one another. St James seems to have more practices but plays fewer tournaments than Monument. And of course, Monument's fees are significantly lower. Based on what I'm reading St James seems to have a better reputation but I haven't seen any recent reviews or feedback on Monument. If you've had experience with either of these clubs, would love to hear from you.