Anonymous wrote:Yeti Camino is superior.

I had to look it up. Get out of here with that obnoxious logo and inflexible base. What's the stuff on the straps? $130, $150, and $200 for these monstrosities?

Zipper. I have both and prefer the zipper.

Yeti Camino is superior.

We have both, but prefer to have the zipper option

Both? I have giant ones with and without. They're both great.

For small and medium, no zipper.

Anonymous wrote:Lands End totes are much better & they have a key holder

I have a zipper top Lands End tote that I love. It's my sports sideline bag.

depends on what you are using it for. I use the smaller one like a purse and like the zipper for that. The bigger one I use for groceries, pool towels, bigger stuff - so I don't need the zipper for that.

Lands End totes are much better & they have a key holder

With zipper.

Zipper!!!!!

No zipper for us, but we only use the really big ones for boat/beach/pool and load them to the gills ofen with things (pool toys) that we want to carry more easily but stick out the top.

^^purse organizer a good idea anyway because the inside has no pockets or anything.

I had the really giant one for the beach--no zipper. Easier to use and very useful fir toting towels, etc.

Purse/smallest size: zipper. But I found it got kind of hard to zip or unzip after a while. The zipper was kind of large in comparison to the size of the bag, if tgat makes sense--large gold zipper teeth. I think I'd buy without if I bought it again.

Absolutely with the zipper. I don't always zip them, but it's nice to be able to.

Open top or not? I feel open top is more common but it’s just so much less secure? Or would a purse organizer solve my issue and work?

Which style has suited you best?