I'd order a tray of sliced beef tenderloin and a tray of crabcakes (choose mini crab cakes could also be an appetizer), 2 sides (one salad, one vegetable), dinner rolls and a Dolly Sin cake for dessert and a veggie tray appetizer. They also have "dinner for 4" ( you'd need 5 of these $$$) and those have sides, etc.
Their sushi is the only non Japanese restaurant sushi we'll eat - it's really good.
Their website is pretty easy and useful
https://catering.balduccis.com/
They're very helpful by phone
1.866.278.8866