We use a realty company - there are two and both are good. The island is almost all houses, so that’s what I would do. It’s super small so any place is as good as another really. Few houses have pools.

If you want a condo, the nearby island of ocean Isle Beach is more built up. The drive from one island to the other would be like 15 minutes.

Its for a wedding on the island, so needs to be convenient . I'm clueless where to start (6 people)

On the island? There is only one hotel and a few condos - not much there. (Which is why we love it!)

Or in the town on the mainland?

Recommended places to stay? Going Sept/Oct.