Anonymous wrote:Thirteen year old children should not be professional referees. It's just a really bad idea. Obviously these coaches should have behaved better, based on your description. But you are just asking for trouble to force the coaches to pretend like the child referee is a serious authority figure on the field who has the judgment and knowledge to call the game fairly and-more importantly-ensure the safety of all the other children playing the game.
Anonymous wrote:So I'm a 50 year old dad with two sons that played soccer (ones still plays) and I coached both when they were younger, I have licenses, etc. I don't coach any longer but I've been reffing with my oldest son for about 6 years and my younger son refs now too. So I've seen my share of matches at well over the years. So your daughter is 13 so a brand new ref (how many matches under her belt?) and you thought it was a good idea to allow her to solo ref (because U11s don't have full crews at this tournament) a 9v9 boys match where she needs to watch offside on both ends, watch the goal line on both ends, and touch line to touch line and you thought it was going to end well? And if you watched as many matches as you said, you should know that this age and level is prime for psychotic parents and coaches. I, personally, would NEVER center this match. Now, should that coach have gave her a hard time?...of course not. That's a huge problem...but you know they do anyway. They are crazy. But you threw your daughter into the fire.
Anonymous wrote:Thirteen year old children should not be professional referees. It's just a really bad idea. Obviously these coaches should have behaved better, based on your description. But you are just asking for trouble to force the coaches to pretend like the child referee is a serious authority figure on the field who has the judgment and knowledge to call the game fairly and-more importantly-ensure the safety of all the other children playing the game.
Anonymous wrote:this maybe the child refs need a safesport portal to keep the coaches honest/at bay.Anonymous wrote:Thirteen year old children should not be professional referees. It's just a really bad idea. Obviously these coaches should have behaved better, based on your description. But you are just asking for trouble to force the coaches to pretend like the child referee is a serious authority figure on the field who has the judgment and knowledge to call the game fairly and-more importantly-ensure the safety of all the other children playing the game.
Call it the abusive game coach portal
this maybe the child refs need a safesport portal to keep the coaches honest/at bay.Anonymous wrote:Thirteen year old children should not be professional referees. It's just a really bad idea. Obviously these coaches should have behaved better, based on your description. But you are just asking for trouble to force the coaches to pretend like the child referee is a serious authority figure on the field who has the judgment and knowledge to call the game fairly and-more importantly-ensure the safety of all the other children playing the game.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:So I'm a 50 year old dad with two sons that played soccer (ones still plays) and I coached both when they were younger, I have licenses, etc. I don't coach any longer but I've been reffing with my oldest son for about 6 years and my younger son refs now too. So I've seen my share of matches at well over the years. So your daughter is 13 so a brand new ref (how many matches under her belt?) and you thought it was a good idea to allow her to solo ref (because U11s don't have full crews at this tournament) a 9v9 boys match where she needs to watch offside on both ends, watch the goal line on both ends, and touch line to touch line and you thought it was going to end well? And if you watched as many matches as you said, you should know that this age and level is prime for psychotic parents and coaches. I, personally, would NEVER center this match. Now, should that coach have gave her a hard time?...of course not. That's a huge problem...but you know they do anyway. They are crazy. But you threw your daughter into the fire.
Your victim blaming is delightful.
Look, my 14 year old son also refs rec games- because it’s a decent job that pays well. Hes also doing it because they can’t fill the roles with older refs. Why? Because of parents. If parents don’t improve their behavior on the sidelines, then there will soon be no refs at all for games.
Also, the idea that full grown adult parents of 10 year old rec soccer players don’t recognize that it’s not ok to harrass the 13 year old ref doing her best, is astonishing to me. I’m sure these same parents would go ape shit if someone looked cross-eyed at their own tween.
I am not blaming the victim whatsoever. I agree that grown adults shouldn't say anything to the ref (ESPECIALLY YOUNG TEENS....BUT THEY DO!) I get all your points, but, until the parents and coaches stop acting the way they do, I would NOT have 13 year old daughter solo ref a 9v9 (or even 7v7) tournament game because I know some a-hole is going to say something to her and I would lose my temper and now I'm in the face of the coach/parent and all hell is breaking loose. It's really, really hard for 13/14 year olds to get the experience they need because I believe they need to start off as AR for like a year. But ARs (full crews) start at U13 so they'd be ARing their own age group, which might not be the best. And they just are not ready to solo solo ref. Solo reffing is hard! I wish more rec programs had ARs for their U10s and U11s so young refs can gain more experience. I am not blaming the victim here or at least that is not my intention but having a 13-14 year old solo ref a tournament game is crazy to me. You are asking for trouble.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:So I'm a 50 year old dad with two sons that played soccer (ones still plays) and I coached both when they were younger, I have licenses, etc. I don't coach any longer but I've been reffing with my oldest son for about 6 years and my younger son refs now too. So I've seen my share of matches at well over the years. So your daughter is 13 so a brand new ref (how many matches under her belt?) and you thought it was a good idea to allow her to solo ref (because U11s don't have full crews at this tournament) a 9v9 boys match where she needs to watch offside on both ends, watch the goal line on both ends, and touch line to touch line and you thought it was going to end well? And if you watched as many matches as you said, you should know that this age and level is prime for psychotic parents and coaches. I, personally, would NEVER center this match. Now, should that coach have gave her a hard time?...of course not. That's a huge problem...but you know they do anyway. They are crazy. But you threw your daughter into the fire.
Your victim blaming is delightful.
Look, my 14 year old son also refs rec games- because it’s a decent job that pays well. Hes also doing it because they can’t fill the roles with older refs. Why? Because of parents. If parents don’t improve their behavior on the sidelines, then there will soon be no refs at all for games.
Also, the idea that full grown adult parents of 10 year old rec soccer players don’t recognize that it’s not ok to harrass the 13 year old ref doing her best, is astonishing to me. I’m sure these same parents would go ape shit if someone looked cross-eyed at their own tween.
Anonymous wrote:So I'm a 50 year old dad with two sons that played soccer (ones still plays) and I coached both when they were younger, I have licenses, etc. I don't coach any longer but I've been reffing with my oldest son for about 6 years and my younger son refs now too. So I've seen my share of matches at well over the years. So your daughter is 13 so a brand new ref (how many matches under her belt?) and you thought it was a good idea to allow her to solo ref (because U11s don't have full crews at this tournament) a 9v9 boys match where she needs to watch offside on both ends, watch the goal line on both ends, and touch line to touch line and you thought it was going to end well? And if you watched as many matches as you said, you should know that this age and level is prime for psychotic parents and coaches. I, personally, would NEVER center this match. Now, should that coach have gave her a hard time?...of course not. That's a huge problem...but you know they do anyway. They are crazy. But you threw your daughter into the fire.