Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My experience isn't made up, OP. But I have also been abusive, as a response to his abuse. There comes a point in a toxic relationship where it brings you down to the same level. You can't always go high, because sometimes you're cornered and you need to fight (verbally or physically).

I know two women who lied about being abused by their relatives or their spouse. They were both in full-blown paranoid episodes stemming from psychiatric treatment refusal. They both had a bipolar disorder diagnoses. Maybe there was also something else going on, who knows. Psychiatry is not an exact science and there is still plenty we don't know.

I also note that "abuse" encompasses a great many things, minor and/or major. Some humans verbalize or otherwise exteriorize their feelings a lot more than others.

***There is little relation between how much a person expresses their pain and how much pain they actually felt!***

And there is no way to know.

So we should focus on the path to economic and psychiatric recovery. Both are quantifiable, objective measures. It's all we can do.

welll …. I’d argue that if you think it was a “mutual abuse” situation, you shouldn’t be in a DV groups for women who may geniunely fear for their lives and experienced much more severe abuse. This isn’t to say that fighting back at times means the woman wasn’t the victim or that she has to be perfect. But it does mean that if you didn’t experience actual domination and control you should bow out of a DV group.

My exEH engaged in some “mild” abusive behavior (grabbing my phone, blocking me from leaving, one time when he followed me around a mall demanding an apology). And a lot of lower key control through escalating verbal tactics. But I’m not a “DV victim” and would never join a DV group for women actual beaten by their partners.

Anonymous wrote:Are you seeing them as exaggerating as a way of minimizing the trauma of your experience? To avoid confronting it in its full reality or to avoid feeling weak?

Anonymous wrote:My experience isn't made up, OP. But I have also been abusive, as a response to his abuse. There comes a point in a toxic relationship where it brings you down to the same level. You can't always go high, because sometimes you're cornered and you need to fight (verbally or physically).

I know two women who lied about being abused by their relatives or their spouse. They were both in full-blown paranoid episodes stemming from psychiatric treatment refusal. They both had a bipolar disorder diagnoses. Maybe there was also something else going on, who knows. Psychiatry is not an exact science and there is still plenty we don't know.

I also note that "abuse" encompasses a great many things, minor and/or major. Some humans verbalize or otherwise exteriorize their feelings a lot more than others.

***There is little relation between how much a person expresses their pain and how much pain they actually felt!***

And there is no way to know.

So we should focus on the path to economic and psychiatric recovery. Both are quantifiable, objective measures. It's all we can do.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:
I’ve come to believe a not insubstantial number of these women - maybe 10 percent overall- are the abusive ones themselves and/or lying or exaggerating about their abuse. There is a real strain of histrionics with some of them and it makes my skin crawl. They have found supportive groups like the one I’m in where they can feel validated and wrap themselves in victimhood, ignoring any personal accountability for their lives.

I dont know how to deal with them in our group events. Ignore?

Given that you are in the group one assumes you are a survivor. Given this, consider how easy you have just proven it to be for those not affected to doubt anyone/everyone who claims to be a survivor.

Stop assuming you know how one person's abuse and trauma impacts their behavior and concentrate on your own healing.

You do not help anyone by fixating on whether others are believable or not. It's not your job nor your responsibility.

Offer support and receive it, otherwise get out of the group.

Anonymous wrote:
I’ve come to believe a not insubstantial number of these women - maybe 10 percent overall- are the abusive ones themselves and/or lying or exaggerating about their abuse. There is a real strain of histrionics with some of them and it makes my skin crawl. They have found supportive groups like the one I’m in where they can feel validated and wrap themselves in victimhood, ignoring any personal accountability for their lives.

I dont know how to deal with them in our group events. Ignore?

Anonymous wrote:My experience isn't made up, OP. But I have also been abusive, as a response to his abuse. There comes a point in a toxic relationship where it brings you down to the same level. You can't always go high, because sometimes you're cornered and you need to fight (verbally or physically).

I know two women who lied about being abused by their relatives or their spouse. They were both in full-blown paranoid episodes stemming from psychiatric treatment refusal. They both had a bipolar disorder diagnoses. Maybe there was also something else going on, who knows. Psychiatry is not an exact science and there is still plenty we don't know.

I also note that "abuse" encompasses a great many things, minor and/or major. Some humans verbalize or otherwise exteriorize their feelings a lot more than others.

***There is little relation between how much a person expresses their pain and how much pain they actually felt!***

And there is no way to know.

So we should focus on the path to economic and psychiatric recovery. Both are quantifiable, objective measures. It's all we can do.