I love my ghosts but will now look at the Hilma shoes.

It doesn't matter. Running shoes are completely individual. What works for one person will not work for another and cause a ton of pain. Go to a local running store like RnJ and buy what they tell you to.

Had not even heard of them, but I’m always on the lookout for wide toebox shoes. I’m a fan of the Altra Rivera, but I read they shrunk the toebox on the more recent versions.

I have also liked Ghost, which you mentioned, and other Brooks.

Keep seeing them advertised, and see that REI sells them. I have small feet with high arches but a wide toe box, and these are supposed to address that. I most recently wore Hokas and zbrooks Ghodt, but they’re not working for me like they used to and I have PF that won’t go away. Would be interested to see if anyone else had tried them.