I think it really comes down to fit and feel on your body. Patagonia has changed their fit so many times over the past decade, it just no longer predictable and I don't think the quality is quite what it used to be.
I have switched over and now mostly wear Arc'teryx, HH, or Fjallraven. Seems like HH is finally making a big comeback (I wore it a good bit in the 90s), and I love it. Their styles and fits are practical and products long-lasting IMO.