Anonymous wrote:It baffles me why people would come and ask such silly questions. Where is the common sense?
what is silly? the OP asked a very specific question about water resistant/breathable jackets vs. waterproof ones and even stated a reason why they were asking. Sounds like a reasonable question to me.
Here's my not totally responsive answer: my son goes the cold gear under layer route mentioned above. We don't use a water resistant jacket in training because he won't be able to use it in a match, and might not be prepared to handle a cold, rainy match day.