Anonymous wrote:I would also suggest rec, especially for volleyball (basketball would be a little harder because players start earlier). There will be plenty of beginners and most balls will drop on the court. There will be celebration when the serve makes it over the net and something close to a miracle when it comes back. She will realize that it is normal for everyone to start somewhere.
This was pretty much what I was going to say.
Personal training becomes a bit more worthwhile once kids learn the basics of a sport and then personal training helps them get better.
Rec is generally great place to start. It does get harder to get into as kids get older because they're playing against kids who have been playing for several years and are competitive. But we've seen beginners join in at later ages and some sports are easier to get into at a later age than others.
What really makes a difference is parents working with their kids. Where even if parents don't know the sport, they can look up some exercises on youtube and have their kids work on it.
For example in volleyball you can toss her the ball and have her practice receiving it, setting it, serving, etc. With basketball you can find some drills online for her to do to get comfortable with ball handling and take her out to a court to have her practice layups, shots, etc.
And for both basketball and volleyball, there should be instructional classes as well. But I know you said that she doesn't want to do group classes at the moment. I also found that kids who make their first transition from instructional classes to actual game play have some initial difficulty in adjusting to the pressure of actual game play against an opponent trying to win. So strongly recommend signing your child up for rec so they can get the in game experience too and as the other poster mentioned there is some value in working in a group environment.
And I do know some families that weren't comfortable working with their kids on that kind of thing and did hire a personal coach (initially through coachup). And their kid made a pretty noticeable improvement from not knowing how to play at all to being pretty decent in a short amount of time. But at the same time I think their kid probably practiced a lot on their own in between the personal training sessions. I kind of question if the cost is worth it but I guess it does work.