I would take a $250 statement credit -- nicely offsets the higher fee.
FWIW, I'm not a power user but I find the Platinum benefits to be easy to use and get enough value out of it to more than cover the fee. If you use the airline credits, Uber cash, streaming benefits, Saks credits, etc., they add up.
I review my annual fee cards every year to make sure I am getting enough value to justify the fee. The Platinum card is never an issue. I also have Gold find it much harder to maximize the value. I'll probably end up canceling it this year. So if you downgrade, I'd take Green over Gold.