Anonymous
04/13/2024 16:15
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Anyone have feedback about ELC at Barnsley? DC in lottery but not selected.
Anonymous
04/13/2024 14:43
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please search this board if you have energy to do so as it has been discussed. If you feel comfortable to mention name of school, someone may be able to provide more details on what the enrichment entails. In our experience, not much: was placed in a small group with other students in a class that had 5 different reading groups. Those students in our kid's group also were probably placed in the CES lottery but not accepted. While teacher met with the reading group(s) needing assistance, the "enriched" group met and can't remember if read silently or aloud. The teacher met with the "enriched" group several times but at the moment blanking on how often. Writing based on readings and some research on various social studies or science topics (e.g. natural disasters). You should just plan to enrich at home as your kid needs, and as you probably have anyways if your kid was placed in a lottery.
+1 whether your experience with ELC is a good one largely depends on the quality of the teacher. Ours is a huge disappointment. Very unhelpful and talks at people. Once again with mcps it’s a DIY situation.
Forgot to add that the curriculum is underwhelming: the same worksheets, she does not correct basic grammar or spelling, not to mention giving substantive critique. She relies on students to give each other feedback.
That’s a teacher issue, not a curriculum issue.
DP
No, actually. We talked to our ES kid’s teacher and she specifically said they are instructed to not correct grammar and spelling.
And peer review is something that is also done system-wide.
Peer review continues in middle school and high. While some teachers are thorough in providing feedback, most not so; they have 150+ students.
Anonymous
04/13/2024 14:31
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please search this board if you have energy to do so as it has been discussed. If you feel comfortable to mention name of school, someone may be able to provide more details on what the enrichment entails. In our experience, not much: was placed in a small group with other students in a class that had 5 different reading groups. Those students in our kid's group also were probably placed in the CES lottery but not accepted. While teacher met with the reading group(s) needing assistance, the "enriched" group met and can't remember if read silently or aloud. The teacher met with the "enriched" group several times but at the moment blanking on how often. Writing based on readings and some research on various social studies or science topics (e.g. natural disasters). You should just plan to enrich at home as your kid needs, and as you probably have anyways if your kid was placed in a lottery.
+1 whether your experience with ELC is a good one largely depends on the quality of the teacher. Ours is a huge disappointment. Very unhelpful and talks at people. Once again with mcps it’s a DIY situation.
Forgot to add that the curriculum is underwhelming: the same worksheets, she does not correct basic grammar or spelling, not to mention giving substantive critique. She relies on students to give each other feedback.
That’s a teacher issue, not a curriculum issue.
DP
No, actually. We talked to our ES kid’s teacher and she specifically said they are instructed to not correct grammar and spelling.
And peer review is something that is also done system-wide.
Anonymous
04/13/2024 14:16
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Depends on school as others have said or even by year. DC1 who got it was in a full class of about 26-27 students reading Junior Great Books I think they were called. DC2 got an occasional pull out where they read shorter stories or parts of longer books. I think that was about 2x a month but really just depended on teacher availability.
Anonymous
04/13/2024 12:48
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please search this board if you have energy to do so as it has been discussed. If you feel comfortable to mention name of school, someone may be able to provide more details on what the enrichment entails. In our experience, not much: was placed in a small group with other students in a class that had 5 different reading groups. Those students in our kid's group also were probably placed in the CES lottery but not accepted. While teacher met with the reading group(s) needing assistance, the "enriched" group met and can't remember if read silently or aloud. The teacher met with the "enriched" group several times but at the moment blanking on how often. Writing based on readings and some research on various social studies or science topics (e.g. natural disasters). You should just plan to enrich at home as your kid needs, and as you probably have anyways if your kid was placed in a lottery.
+1 whether your experience with ELC is a good one largely depends on the quality of the teacher. Ours is a huge disappointment. Very unhelpful and talks at people. Once again with mcps it’s a DIY situation.
Forgot to add that the curriculum is underwhelming: the same worksheets, she does not correct basic grammar or spelling, not to mention giving substantive critique. She relies on students to give each other feedback.
That’s a teacher issue, not a curriculum issue.
+1 You should speak with the teacher/reading specialist and/or principal. ELC absolutely does not use the same curriculum
Anonymous
04/13/2024 11:04
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please search this board if you have energy to do so as it has been discussed. If you feel comfortable to mention name of school, someone may be able to provide more details on what the enrichment entails. In our experience, not much: was placed in a small group with other students in a class that had 5 different reading groups. Those students in our kid's group also were probably placed in the CES lottery but not accepted. While teacher met with the reading group(s) needing assistance, the "enriched" group met and can't remember if read silently or aloud. The teacher met with the "enriched" group several times but at the moment blanking on how often. Writing based on readings and some research on various social studies or science topics (e.g. natural disasters). You should just plan to enrich at home as your kid needs, and as you probably have anyways if your kid was placed in a lottery.
+1 whether your experience with ELC is a good one largely depends on the quality of the teacher. Ours is a huge disappointment. Very unhelpful and talks at people. Once again with mcps it’s a DIY situation.
Forgot to add that the curriculum is underwhelming: the same worksheets, she does not correct basic grammar or spelling, not to mention giving substantive critique. She relies on students to give each other feedback.
That’s a teacher issue, not a curriculum issue.
Anonymous
04/13/2024 10:07
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please search this board if you have energy to do so as it has been discussed. If you feel comfortable to mention name of school, someone may be able to provide more details on what the enrichment entails. In our experience, not much: was placed in a small group with other students in a class that had 5 different reading groups. Those students in our kid's group also were probably placed in the CES lottery but not accepted. While teacher met with the reading group(s) needing assistance, the "enriched" group met and can't remember if read silently or aloud. The teacher met with the "enriched" group several times but at the moment blanking on how often. Writing based on readings and some research on various social studies or science topics (e.g. natural disasters). You should just plan to enrich at home as your kid needs, and as you probably have anyways if your kid was placed in a lottery.
+1 whether your experience with ELC is a good one largely depends on the quality of the teacher. Ours is a huge disappointment. Very unhelpful and talks at people. Once again with mcps it’s a DIY situation.
Forgot to add that the curriculum is underwhelming: the same worksheets, she does not correct basic grammar or spelling, not to mention giving substantive critique. She relies on students to give each other feedback.
Anonymous
04/13/2024 10:04
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Anonymous wrote:Please search this board if you have energy to do so as it has been discussed. If you feel comfortable to mention name of school, someone may be able to provide more details on what the enrichment entails. In our experience, not much: was placed in a small group with other students in a class that had 5 different reading groups. Those students in our kid's group also were probably placed in the CES lottery but not accepted. While teacher met with the reading group(s) needing assistance, the "enriched" group met and can't remember if read silently or aloud. The teacher met with the "enriched" group several times but at the moment blanking on how often. Writing based on readings and some research on various social studies or science topics (e.g. natural disasters). You should just plan to enrich at home as your kid needs, and as you probably have anyways if your kid was placed in a lottery.
+1 whether your experience with ELC is a good one largely depends on the quality of the teacher. Ours is a huge disappointment. Very unhelpful and talks at people. Once again with mcps it’s a DIY situation.
Anonymous
04/12/2024 17:25
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Please search this board if you have energy to do so as it has been discussed. If you feel comfortable to mention name of school, someone may be able to provide more details on what the enrichment entails. In our experience, not much: was placed in a small group with other students in a class that had 5 different reading groups. Those students in our kid's group also were probably placed in the CES lottery but not accepted. While teacher met with the reading group(s) needing assistance, the "enriched" group met and can't remember if read silently or aloud. The teacher met with the "enriched" group several times but at the moment blanking on how often. Writing based on readings and some research on various social studies or science topics (e.g. natural disasters). You should just plan to enrich at home as your kid needs, and as you probably have anyways if your kid was placed in a lottery.
Anonymous
04/12/2024 17:15
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
Student should be included in the ELC class at home school. Talk to reading specialist or principal.
Anonymous
04/12/2024 17:11
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
The experience has been reported as somewhat variable among local schools. Ask the reading specialist. Ask for specifics.
Anonymous
04/12/2024 16:54
Subject: rising 4th - met criteria for literacy enrichment, did not get seat in the CES lottery
I received a MCPS letter that my child met the "central criteria for literacy enrichment and will receive literacy enrichment in grades 4 and 5". It further says that my DC was entered into the lottery pool for a CES seat but did not get placed and so will receive literacy enrichment at their current/home school. What does this mean in practice? Will there be a group of students all receiving the enriched curriculum at the home school or is it just one of those things where they get enrichment by perhaps reading a more difficult book, etc.? Thanks.