Anonymous wrote:I look back at the friends and family whose lives I envy, and they each one thing - they were a part of something larger than themselves, a group that had kinship-like ties. Whether that was college athletics, the military, even an MLB player, they were part of a "exclusive" community. There's nothing like that for a woman pushing 50, right?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Your question rubs me the wrong way, OP. Instead of contributing something useful to society, you want to be part of an exclusive group, regardless of which one it is?
DH and I are research scientists who work in cancer research. The people I most admire have always been the people who serve humanity through their profession or their volunteer work. Teachers, nurses, managers of soup kitchens or animal shelters, specialists who risk their lives working for Doctors Without Borders on the frontlines of war. My cousin, who works for an organization building refugee camps for Syrians in North Africa.
Such people, as a group, have my entire admiration and respect.
I'm glad you have ways of meeting your community needs. I do not. I am absolutely, 100% alone. It's devastated my mental health. Your insistence that I don't deserve both community and being of use to society rubs me the wrong way.
No, we're clearly getting the message that the usual volunteering circuit is beneath you and that you "want to be part of an exclusive community"! You realize that you cited extremely challenging professions - military, major league baseball and college athletics - none of which are accessible to you at this time?
You seem to suffer from delusions of grandeur. I know people in middle age who have embarked on marvelous adventures (sailing around the world, climbing the world's highest peaks, starting an entirely new career), but these people had a goal centered around a passion. They knew what they wanted, fundraised, prepared for years. They didn't expend considerable energy and effort doing what they did "to be part of something larger than themselves". Their focus was narrow and intense.
You're not going anywhere with that attitude.
Anonymous wrote:I look back at the friends and family whose lives I envy, and they each one thing - they were a part of something larger than themselves, a group that had kinship-like ties. Whether that was college athletics, the military, even an MLB player, they were part of a "exclusive" community. There's nothing like that for a woman pushing 50, right?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Your question rubs me the wrong way, OP. Instead of contributing something useful to society, you want to be part of an exclusive group, regardless of which one it is?
DH and I are research scientists who work in cancer research. The people I most admire have always been the people who serve humanity through their profession or their volunteer work. Teachers, nurses, managers of soup kitchens or animal shelters, specialists who risk their lives working for Doctors Without Borders on the frontlines of war. My cousin, who works for an organization building refugee camps for Syrians in North Africa.
Such people, as a group, have my entire admiration and respect.
I'm glad you have ways of meeting your community needs. I do not. I am absolutely, 100% alone. It's devastated my mental health. Your insistence that I don't deserve both community and being of use to society rubs me the wrong way.
Anonymous wrote:I would be wary of this OP. I know people who have found or created communities like this in their lives and I don't think it's always good. Like... a cult is an "exclusive" community with "kinship-like" ties. So are some cult-adjacent organizations.
A lot of people get a lot of personal validation out of being a member of a group that others are excluded from. If that's you, I would ask yourself why that aspect is important to you. Why does it make you feel better to know that you were "chosen" over other people? What is it about your mental make up that makes you crave that kind of selection?
Anonymous wrote:Your question rubs me the wrong way, OP. Instead of contributing something useful to society, you want to be part of an exclusive group, regardless of which one it is?
DH and I are research scientists who work in cancer research. The people I most admire have always been the people who serve humanity through their profession or their volunteer work. Teachers, nurses, managers of soup kitchens or animal shelters, specialists who risk their lives working for Doctors Without Borders on the frontlines of war. My cousin, who works for an organization building refugee camps for Syrians in North Africa.
Such people, as a group, have my entire admiration and respect.
Anonymous wrote:Ties with people is different than seeking an identity rooted in a "cause" OP.
I know people who have found ties in a group by joining a church or meditation community, for example, in mid-life.
Why not focus on strengthening ties to the friends and family you mention, creating shared happy joint memories, etc.?