Neutral is neutral. I don’t think skin tone matters here. Regardless of skin color, generally nail color looks the same.

OPI Put it in neutral is nice. Also like Essie Fairy Taylor.

Same skin color and I use Essie buns up and mademoiselle (it’s not too pink).

Would OPI Substantially Tan work?

I use a white pearl color. When I want to be glam, I choose a chrome. It shows well on my tan skin.

I have a warm olive to tan skin tone and have no idea what “neutral” to use on nails - what I choose usually ends up looking too light or pink. Any suggestions? (Closest skin tone is Aubrey Plaza or Jenna Ortega.)