Anonymous wrote:That's my question. I like peanut butter sandwiches on white or wheat bread. I like sourdough bread for other types of sandwiches, like with meat. I want to try a sourdough peanut butter sandwich but something about it seems weird. Like, the tangy bread and sweet peanut butter won't go together well. Yes, I know, just try it. But I value your opinion.

You can make a sandwich on whatever bread you want.

Yes. Toast the bread.

You know what's good on sour dough? Cream cheese and pepper jelly.

I would do it in a pinch. I.e. really want a peanut butter sandwich but only have sourdough. I wouldn't seek it out.

Grilled cheese on sourdough on the other hand ... fantastic.

This "I value your opinion" stuff makes no sense when it comes to what you like to eat. Put some peanut butter on some sourdough and taste it.

I will eat anything on sourdough

I would toast it.

Yeah, try it and see. I think I’d like it better with another ingredient in the mix — so, maybe peanut butter and bacon, a combo that I haven’t had in decades. Also, my peanut butter isn’t sweet: just peanuts and salt. So could be worth trying with a few different types of peanut butter if you really want to give this combination a chance to beguile you.

Thank you for your insights. You're so wonderful to take your time to help me. Have a nice weekend!
-- OP

Anonymous wrote:I like it but I use natural peanut butter that isn't very sweet.

On the other hand, I'd use a bit more sweetener to balance the slightly sour bread. I prefer honey but you could use the traditional jelly.

As you see, tastes differ, so just try it.

I like it but I use natural peanut butter that isn't very sweet.

I do! But I make it on homemade sourdough, which doesn’t have additives to make it extra tangy.

It s not a combination that sounds appealing to me...but just try it to satisfy your curiosity.

Some people like them! I think it's gross but when I tried it when I was out of regular bread, one of the people I was with thought it was great. Just make half a sandwich if you're worried about waste.

That's my question. I like peanut butter sandwiches on white or wheat bread. I like sourdough bread for other types of sandwiches, like with meat. I want to try a sourdough peanut butter sandwich but something about it seems weird. Like, the tangy bread and sweet peanut butter won't go together well. Yes, I know, just try it. But I value your opinion.