Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 21:56     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.



i'm confused why you think a public PTA is "powerful" or will have the money to take this on????


I have faith in the Langley parents.


You're mistaken. At Madison, it was presented to the parents after the school hired outside people to explore how to implement it. I believe they even have information they presented to the admin that was released explaining how to respond when parents push back. Parents were only told about it after it was going to happen. Last year's seniors spoke at a PTA meeting and explained it is horrible. Parents complain. Teachers complain. The admin is in la la land and thinks it is great because the bottom is brought up. PERIOD. There was never a period where they solicited input from parents or students and then considered what to do. Instead, it was 100% a done deal and presented only after it was being implemented. There is no push back. There is no powerful PTA who can override this.


So weird how they made a decision based on educational research and child psychology instead of parents and kids' opinions.

Also weird: implementing the alleged "equity" grading system in a school that doesn't have a large group of lower performing students.

Maybe this policy (ill-advised or not) is intended to help all students learn more, not equalize them. And really...think about this argument that SBG is just a veiled attempt to create "equity"...that doesn't even make sense at the HS level: the kids who need a GPA boost aren't in the same classes as the kids who are supposedly being down-graded by SBG. How would the admin be engineering "equity" when students are pre-sorting themselves by the classes they take. Colleges look at the difficulty of classes you take, not just your gpa.

Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 21:55     Subject: Re:Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
The Madison PTSA board has someone on it that likes to help the principal out with SBG.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 21:28     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
We've been told it's coming next year to all schools.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 21:08     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
If they were looking for an “equity” school to try this with wouldn’t they have gone to an economically diverse school with some wealthy pockets and some high FARMS areas? Not that I want to give them any ideas but a school like South Lakes, Westfield, or South County instead of pretty well off and well performing schools like Madison HS and Irving Middle? It really seems ill-advised overall and like the teachers aren’t even buying into it.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 20:59     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.



i'm confused why you think a public PTA is "powerful" or will have the money to take this on????


I have faith in the Langley parents.


You're mistaken. At Madison, it was presented to the parents after the school hired outside people to explore how to implement it. I believe they even have information they presented to the admin that was released explaining how to respond when parents push back. Parents were only told about it after it was going to happen. Last year's seniors spoke at a PTA meeting and explained it is horrible. Parents complain. Teachers complain. The admin is in la la land and thinks it is great because the bottom is brought up. PERIOD. There was never a period where they solicited input from parents or students and then considered what to do. Instead, it was 100% a done deal and presented only after it was being implemented. There is no push back. There is no powerful PTA who can override this.


There is hardly a "bottom" at Madison. The 5% of ELL kids falling their SOLs won't make a dent in the outcomes when they compare SBG to traditional grading. Equity is quite simply not the driving factor.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 20:51     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.



i'm confused why you think a public PTA is "powerful" or will have the money to take this on????


I have faith in the Langley parents.


You're mistaken. At Madison, it was presented to the parents after the school hired outside people to explore how to implement it. I believe they even have information they presented to the admin that was released explaining how to respond when parents push back. Parents were only told about it after it was going to happen. Last year's seniors spoke at a PTA meeting and explained it is horrible. Parents complain. Teachers complain. The admin is in la la land and thinks it is great because the bottom is brought up. PERIOD. There was never a period where they solicited input from parents or students and then considered what to do. Instead, it was 100% a done deal and presented only after it was being implemented. There is no push back. There is no powerful PTA who can override this.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 20:31     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.



i'm confused why you think a public PTA is "powerful" or will have the money to take this on????


I have faith in the Langley parents.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 20:02     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.


Why would the PTA at any other HS be more “powerful” than the Madison PTA? [/quote]


No public PTA has this kind of power or interest
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 19:49     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.


Why would the PTA at any other HS be more “powerful” than the Madison PTA?
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 19:40     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.



i'm confused why you think a public PTA is "powerful" or will have the money to take this on????
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 19:37     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?


This is my fondest hope. That this madness will extend to the schools with powerful PTAs who will lobby against it for the rest of us.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 17:44     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Anonymous wrote:Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?



OMG time for private school
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 17:40     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Can anyone speak to Chantilly HS?
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 10:31     Subject: Re:Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
^^^^ “grading” not trading.
Anonymous
Post 11/14/2023 10:31     Subject: Equity-grading/ SBG - all FCPS high schools? (or only some)
Is the policy now county-wide in FFX?

Or, are only certain high schools doing this? Is there a list??

(anyone know specifically if McLean HS is implementing equity/SBG trading?