Anonymous wrote:Got these to give out for Halloween. Best I’ve gotten from a store, but edited to try those listed upthread.

https://browniepointsinc.com/gourmet-buckeyes

*excited to try

Got these to give out for Halloween. Best I’ve gotten from a store, but edited to try those listed upthread.

https://browniepointsinc.com/gourmet-buckeyes

My grandma used to make these. So good.

Anonymous wrote:Native Ohioan. This NE Ohio bakery sells buckeyes and kolachis that taste just like my grandma used to make.

https://buttermaidbakery.com/

I’ve only had baked goods from Buttermaid Bakery, but their kolachis and cookies are amazing.

Anonymous wrote:It's just peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate, it's not really something you send as a gift, it's something you make and enjoy at home or give as a homemade gift. I would never buy buckeyes in a store, LOL!

You’re missing out. So much better from a store.

Anonymous wrote:I know someone in Ohio who had a confectionery store…hang on. Lemme look it up.

Buckeye Candy Co!

Native Ohioan. This NE Ohio bakery sells buckeyes and kolachis that taste just like my grandma used to make.

https://buttermaidbakery.com/

Etsy!

I know someone in Ohio who had a confectionery store…hang on. Lemme look it up.

I order a lot from Nuts.com and it looks like they have Buckeyes. I have never ordered their buckeyes so I don’t know about them specifically.

https://nuts.com/search/instant?query=buckeyes

OK thanks everyone!

Amazon and Williams Sonoma sells boxes Buckeyes!

You could try Goldbelly. They sell everything.

It's just peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate, it's not really something you send as a gift, it's something you make and enjoy at home or give as a homemade gift. I would never buy buckeyes in a store, LOL!

Has anyone ever heard of these? They are candies consisting of peanut butter fudge dipped in chocolate. I’m interested in sending them as a holiday present— just looking for the best online resource.

Any help is appreciated. Thanks!