Anonymous wrote:+1 for Aruba and Grand Cayman
Grand Cayman is easy to get to (some nonstops from BWI), supposedly the safest island in the Caribbean, and easy to get around. Definitely not a just stay at your resort or in the big tourist zone kind of place. You can rent a car and drive around to different beaches, try all kinds of roadside restaurants, explore caves, visit historical sites, snorkel and scuba. Just keep an eye on sargassum as the season approaches so you can give yourself realistic expectations for how enjoyable beaches on different parts of the island will be, and be aware things are expensive.