Anonymous wrote:OP here- we currently just have a fishing boat but would like to get a pontoon. The lake is VERY small- 90 acres and really just has the one beach that has a playground (our kids are little right now), a little pub that serves food, and then is used for fishing, kayaking, paddle boarding. The bigger lake is 500+ acres and we would have to get on the waitlist for a slip on the big lake which is about 2 years right now (it used to be 15 year wait when I was a kid). The bigger lake has several sand bars for hanging out, water sports, 2 beaches, 2 parks, a few cafes and bars you can boat up to, etc.
Wait it out and get the location you want. Doesn't sound like the vibes are comparable. Any chance you can get on the waitlist now for a slip?