Anonymous wrote:B+ as a sophomore, not really, but the B- as a junior is not helpful. He's not eliminated straight off the bat, assuming test scores, overall GPA, rec letters, etc. are excellent, but I would be certain to be sure that there are schools on his list that are not as selective, and maybe remove a school or two (Notre Dame.) This is assuming he is an unhooked uppper middle class white kid.
Don't panic until you see his AP test score. If he gets a 5, that may help.
Also, was it one of the more difficult APs (APUSH, Physics C, Bio, etc.)? That may also give him a little grace.
Wrong. No grace. Don’t keep his hopes up like that. Reiterate that he had very little chance to begin with, and add some other schools to the list.