Anonymous
05/05/2023 09:19
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
You again with the AP tests, SAT & subject tests that COST MONEY TO TAKE
Anonymous
05/05/2023 09:17
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Come on guys just do basic math. 3.6 million students graduate each year and 1% of that is 36,000 correct? And that’s nearly double what the ivy league can take each year.
When you consider that top schools take from well beyond the top 1% to fulfill their needs do you realize it’s a simple math problem and rearranging the deck chairs will not suddenly result in no one feeling that they were cheated.
The nirvana you think you seek is only possible if applicants realize that there are more than 20 great colleges in the country and that if they are a top performer, they are likely to get into one.
Do the math, most of them should be able to get in t20 schools though.
I personally think T60 is pretty much great.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 09:15
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
As someone who used to be an academic star in high school back when tutoring wasn't so prevalent, when I read your list, my mind mentally automatically adds up the hours/$$ of tutoring/prep and the parental involvement for most of the kids on your list to achieve those "accomplishments."
Yes, some will have done it naturally. They are the real thing. Others were hoisted there, going past others who may not have had that support. It's a game now and I don't take the things you list at face value anymore.
Indeed, how many hours and $$ in private coaches have kids/parents spent for recruited athletes ?
Anonymous
05/05/2023 09:12
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
No. You can't control your class size. Many (most?) PS do not have over 500 per class. So right there, we're saying you have to go to one of those schools to be considered stronger academically? That makes so much sense.
Also boomer, there are no more subject tests. Or are the 1% only kids in HS before 2021, as well?
Anonymous
05/05/2023 09:07
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
So, you just eliminate any kid who attended a high school under 2K students, or who did IB, or Dual enrollment, etc. . . ?
Also, not sure how it's twisted to say that academics aren't the only kind of accomplishment that's important. It's twisted to say that they are. None of the elite schools claims to be accepting kids just based on academics.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 09:06
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
As someone who used to be an academic star in high school back when tutoring wasn't so prevalent, when I read your list, my mind mentally automatically adds up the hours/$$ of tutoring/prep and the parental involvement for most of the kids on your list to achieve those "accomplishments."
Yes, some will have done it naturally. They are the real thing. Others were hoisted there, going past others who may not have had that support. It's a game now and I don't take the things you list at face value anymore.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 09:03
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Come on guys just do basic math. 3.6 million students graduate each year and 1% of that is 36,000 correct? And that’s nearly double what the ivy league can take each year.
When you consider that top schools take from well beyond the top 1% to fulfill their needs do you realize it’s a simple math problem and rearranging the deck chairs will not suddenly result in no one feeling that they were cheated.
The nirvana you think you seek is only possible if applicants realize that there are more than 20 great colleges in the country and that if they are a top performer, they are likely to get into one.
When you consider that top schools take from well beyond the top 1% to fulfill their needs do you realize it’s a simple math problem and rearranging the deck chairs will not suddenly result in no one feeling that they were cheated.
The nirvana you think you seek is only possible if applicants realize that there are more than 20 great colleges in the country and that if they are a top performer, they are likely to get into one.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 08:58
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
And of course you drove into the ditch.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 08:57
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
What's the source for this?
Anonymous
05/05/2023 08:56
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Simple. Meets ALL of the following criteria
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
Within the first five ranks in a class size of over 500
Scores of over 1550 SAT or 35 ACT in a single attempt. No super scoring.
Scores 5 in most of the 8 or more AP tests taken
Scores of over 750 in every one of Subject tests if taken
Very likely around 5,000-10,000 max such students in the whole country. So not many You could easily accommodate every one of them in the top ten schools. But then the diversity goals of the schools would be violated, so they are rejected routinely in favor of less academically accomplished students through all kinds of twisted rationalizations.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 08:16
Subject: Re:What's academic top 1%?
Anonymous wrote:Isn't it 1% at your particular high school's graduation class?
So it's very subjective and less meaningful overall
+1 GPA especially is not comparable. PP above proposed 4.1+ GPA. That's my DDs GPA at a NoVA HS and I think she's barely in the top 25% of her class. Top kids are more like 4.5%+ ( lots of AP, UW 4.0). DDs reflects good number of APs with a mix of As and Bs.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 07:43
Subject: Re:What's academic top 1%?
Isn't it 1% at your particular high school's graduation class?
So it's very subjective and less meaningful overall
So it's very subjective and less meaningful overall
Anonymous
05/05/2023 07:39
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
There is no single definition of 1%. Different colleges value different things.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 06:45
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
A 1530+ SAT with a private school 3.8+ or public school 4.1+ with some sort of independent academic honors as well as other ECs like sports, music, theater, debate etc.
And there are tens of thousands of them in the country with a limited number of seats at the college level. Or they can make it into these schools but the aid isn't sufficient to cover the costs so they choose an alternative.
And there are tens of thousands of them in the country with a limited number of seats at the college level. Or they can make it into these schools but the aid isn't sufficient to cover the costs so they choose an alternative.
Anonymous
05/05/2023 06:40
Subject: What's academic top 1%?
Describe an academic top 1%? How many are there? Why they don't make into ivies?