The black revlon ones are the best I’ve found but they still don’t stay in very well. Hairspray helps, as does clipping two together in an X. Pigtails with the little clear elastics are better.

I used these and other similar ones I found on Amazon when my daughter was little and had kind of wispy, uneven hair that would get in her eyes. Other brands were GBATERI and Shemay. I found the 2-2.5" ones worked well at that age.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01IEUHR2G/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I've never found ones that stayed in reliably, and they are a choking risk. I ended up using small soft hairties, like a 100 pack from Dollar Tree, and sort of doing a Pebbles Flintstone look LOL.

They can't choke on those and for a $1.25 for a 100 (in many colors) I wasn't worried about losing them.

Have you found a brand that works well with very fine hair? I’m looking for something that will stay on and won’t pose a choking risk. DD’s hair is fine and there’s not much of it, but it’s starting to get in her eyes.