Anonymous wrote:My rising jr sounds similar. Schools on the list to look at:
W&M
Mary Washington
Dickinson
Swarthmore
Haverford
College of Wooster
Kenyon
Case Western
Rochester
Carleton
Macalester
Carnegie Mellon
Clark
This is a solid list, but it's criminal not to include Grinnell on it. Grinnell is as good as all and better than most of the schools on the list, is full of students who are exactly as OP described, and is one of the few highly selective colleges that actually is generous with merit aid.