I have two kids-- one who got placed in the Pre-Alg track in 6th grade and one who barely missed the cut-off and was put in the regular 6th grade track. Both of them could have handled Pre-Alg in 6th grade. However, 7th grade is a different story. Intensified Algebra 1 is a hard class with a lot of homework. It counts for high school credit for a reason. So if you decide to appeal, you need to think about 7th grade, and whether your kid is going to be happy taking a high-school level class that year, along with all the homework that comes with it. Most of the 7th graders who were taking Intensified Algebra 1 were doing STEM clubs as their main extracurriculars (Math Counts, etc.) and were competing in CML competitions. The bar was really high to be a superstar in that class, so make sure your kid is going to be okay with that stress level in addition to the academic challenge. After watching my oldest do the 7th grade Intensified Alg 1 track, we opted not to appeal my younger kid's placement. I think APS got it right for both kids, and I rarely say that about APS.
