Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 18:38     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:What do DC got into Yale and Penn and got a better aid package from Penn but prefers Yale. Can we negotiate with Yale?


Penn will not provide as much need based aid as Yale as their formulas are different and Yale is always more generous.

So only the reverse scenario is at all likely, but yes you can try to negotiate need based aid based on a peer school's aid package. Sometimes the package can improve slightly to match another Ivy.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 18:37     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:DC got into Ivy, and now just been offered full scholarship at a state university. Could the Ivy lower the price based on that? We don’t qualify for financial aid.


LOL. One of DC's friends last year had admissions to Penn, Vandy (full ride), michigan and Harvard. They tried to play the Vandy full ride to get something out of Penn and Harvard. No go.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 18:35     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
You would need to qualify for FA, have submitted your FAFSA + been approved under the school's calculator. Otherwise- no. As others wrote-- Ivies do not have merit aid- they do not need to.

We still chose Ivy over nearly free+ it paid off for our kid. No FA at Ivy for us.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 18:14     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:What do DC got into Yale and Penn and got a better aid package from Penn but prefers Yale. Can we negotiate with Yale?


Could people at least try to spot the trolls? How can someone have gotten into both these schools at this point in the admissions cycle? Just use your brain and then ignore


Take it easy. The question was what if.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 18:05     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:What do DC got into Yale and Penn and got a better aid package from Penn but prefers Yale. Can we negotiate with Yale?


Could people at least try to spot the trolls? How can someone have gotten into both these schools at this point in the admissions cycle? Just use your brain and then ignore
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 17:50     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:What do DC got into Yale and Penn and got a better aid package from Penn but prefers Yale. Can we negotiate with Yale?


You can try. I know a family who were successful with this at Yale and Columbia.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 17:46     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:DC got into Ivy, and now just been offered full scholarship at a state university. Could the Ivy lower the price based on that? We don’t qualify for financial aid.


If you don’t qualify for financial aid they aren’t going to give you financial aid.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 17:41     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
What do DC got into Yale and Penn and got a better aid package from Penn but prefers Yale. Can we negotiate with Yale?
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 17:07     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:DC got into Ivy, and now just been offered full scholarship at a state university. Could the Ivy lower the price based on that? We don’t qualify for financial aid.


Ivy schools only give need-based aid. They do not give merit scholarships. So, they will not match another school's merit award.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 16:06     Subject: Re:Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not gonna happen


If your DC got into an Ivy ED then you should have pulled the State U application. If you tell the ED Ivy that you want to negotiate based on a scholarship to a school where you should have pulled the application you might actually be risking your admission spot.

If you got in SCEA then you will just get a flat "no" for an answer. But go ahead and try if you want.


This sounds accurate. If you do not commit to the ED offer for any reason other than the the ones listed, DC is risking the spot.


And SCEA HYP schools will decline to change their aid offers based on the state school scholarship.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 16:04     Subject: Re:Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not gonna happen


If your DC got into an Ivy ED then you should have pulled the State U application. If you tell the ED Ivy that you want to negotiate based on a scholarship to a school where you should have pulled the application you might actually be risking your admission spot.

If you got in SCEA then you will just get a flat "no" for an answer. But go ahead and try if you want.


This sounds accurate. If you do not commit to the ED offer for any reason other than the the ones listed, DC is risking the spot.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 16:00     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Lots of others are happy to pay and take your spot. If you really can’t afford it then go to the state school on scholarship and save your money for grad school.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 15:59     Subject: Re:Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Anonymous wrote:Not gonna happen


If your DC got into an Ivy ED then you should have pulled the State U application. If you tell the ED Ivy that you want to negotiate based on a scholarship to a school where you should have pulled the application you might actually be risking your admission spot.

If you got in SCEA then you will just get a flat "no" for an answer. But go ahead and try if you want.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 15:48     Subject: Re:Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
Not gonna happen
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2022 15:47     Subject: Negotiate financial aid for Ivy?
DC got into Ivy, and now just been offered full scholarship at a state university. Could the Ivy lower the price based on that? We don’t qualify for financial aid.