Have used herbitant for a while never tried nutritant. I noticed the herbitant tends to wash out quickly around the temples for some reason. It looks great at first but does seem to dry out the hair.

I’ve been using Herbatint for almost 4 years now, works great.

I’ve been using Herbatint permanent hair dye since my now 36 year old was in kindergarten! It’s great!!

I’ve been using Herbatint for almost 2 years now and it works great. I have dark brown hair and vary between their 4N-5N shades.

Good luck. You will end up with reddish straw like hair if you go naturalish boxed dye route. There isn’t a natural product out there that will 1) cover gray well 2) not fade/pull red 3) without the big 3 harsh chemicals.

If these things are important to you, you really need to go to a salon that used dyes that have less chemicals

I'm looking for the most organic/natural boxed hair color (I used to go to Aveda salons but am not going to salons anymore). What are the differences between them and which do you recommend? I need to cover grey and lots of it.