Thanks guys- I called Kings Catering in Montclair and told them I couldn't get in through the website so they took me over the phone!

There's a Whole Foods in Montclair, near Nutley. I'd go there.

Citarella does fab Thanksgiving catering. They have a few locations in the city.

Going to my brother's in NJ (Nutley) for Thanksgiving. Said I would bring roasted brussels sprouts. My husband and I have off on Weds so we are going to go up the day before and go out to dinner and stay in the city. I would like to pick up the brussels sprouts already cooked in the city and bring them to him Thursday when I get there. Any idea of where to pick up just sides for catering? Balducci's claims to have a Manhattan location but it's really Scarsdale and they have some off shoot thing called Kings Food, but they don't have any pick up times available! Ugh!