Reply to Class of '26 Instagram College Decisions

Forum Index » Metropolitan New York City

Reply to "Class of '26 Instagram College Decisions"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Only these schools changed adding MIT: Spence +1, Dalton +1, Regis +2, Hunter +2, Fieldston +1.

Also added Hunter, Browning, and Dwight-Englewood

School (N): Ivy+WASP; H/Y/P/S/M; Ivy+

Brearley (46): 36 (78%); 14 (30%); 32 (70%)
Spence (64): 41 (64%); 12 (19%); 38 (59%)
Chapin (52): 32 (62%); 6 (12%); 28 (54%)
Dalton (59): 33 (56%); 13 (22%); 32 (54%)
Saint Ann's (73): 36 (49%); 7 (10%); 27 (37%)
Horace Mann (131): 64 (49%); 6 (5%); 63 (48%)
Trinity (109): 52 (48%); 13 (12%); 49 (45%)
Regis (79): 35 (44%); 6 (8%); 29 (37%)
Nightingale (57): 24 (42%); 1 (2%); 22 (39%)
Riverdale (128): 53 (41%); 11 (9%); 48 (38%)
Hunter (114): 46 (40%); 12 (11%); 42 (37%)
Browning (27): 10 (37%); 2 (7%); 10 (37%)
Packer (92): 28 (30%); 3 (3%); 23 (25%)
Fieldston (141): 42 (30%); 12 (9%); 40 (28%)
Friends Seminary (39): 11 (28%); 2 (5%); 10 (26%)
CGPS (119): 32 (27%); 3 (3%); 28 (24%)
Dwight-Englewood (124): 31 (25%); 8 (6%); 28 (23%)
Avenues (91): 21 (23%); 4 (4%); 20 (22%)
Trevor (87): 16 (18%); 1 (1%); 16 (18%)
Berkeley Carroll (77): 14 (18%); 0 (0%); 9 (12%)
Poly Prep (123): 22 (18%); 2 (2%); 22 (18%)
Grace Church (80): 14 (18%); 1 (1%); 13 (16%)
Sacred Heart (61): 10 (16%); 2 (3%); 10 (16%)
Marymount (70): 8 (11%); 1 (1%); 7 (10%)
Brooklyn Friends (48): 5 (10%); 0 (0%); 3 (6%)

H/Y/P/S/M = Harvard + Yale + Princeton + Stanford + MIT
Ivy+ = Ivy League + Stanford + MIT + Caltech + UChicago + Duke + Johns Hopkins + Northwestern + Vanderbilt
Ivy+WASP = Ivy+ + Williams + Amherst + Swarthmore + Pomona[/quote]

Actual data from schools' websites. 5 year averages where available, otherwise, latest year(s) available averaged.

School                      N/yr    Ivy+WASP H/Y/P/S/M Ivy+      Years (Averaged)
Brearley                   61       60%            19%          53%      2021-2025
Spence                    64       54%            17%          50%      2021-2025
Dalton                      87       52%            16%          48%      2019-2024
Riverdale                 116     46%            11%          43%      2020-2025
Saint Ann's              86       45%            13%          35%      2024-2025
Chapin                     60       43%            11%          38%      2021-2025
Nightingale              57       33%            6%            28%      2021-2025
Fieldston                  120     28%           3%            24%      2020-2025
Browning                 25       25%            3%            23%      2021-2025
Regis                       130     25%            6%            22%      2022-2025
Friends Seminary     74      24%            5%            21%      2021-2025
Packer                     96       19%            5%            16%      2021-2025
Avenues                  91       19%            3%            17%      2023
Dwight-Englewood  124     17%            3%            16%      2023-2025
Sacred Heart           56       16%            3%            15%      2021-2025
Poly Prep                 128     15%           2%            12%      2021-2025
Marymount              50       14%            3%            13%      2020-2024

Horace Mann          180     42%            6%            42%      2023-2025  *** lower bound; missing Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Amherst, Williams; &lt;5 students

BCS, BFS, CGPS, GCS, Hunter, Trevor, Trinity don't report #s, just schools.
[/quote]

I believe Collegiate also reports 5-year data on it's website.[/quote]

Horace Mann (180): 42%; 6%; 42% | 2023-2025 *** lower bound; missing Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Amherst, Williams; badges &lt;5 students[/quote]

Not the PP but if you tier her table by 10% increments on Ivy+WASP, you get these.

[b]50+%[/b]
Brearley (61): 60%; 19%; 53% | 2021-2025
Spence (64): 54%; 17%; 50% | 2021-2025
Collegiate (52): 52%; 12%; 48% | 2020-2024
Dalton (87): 52%; 16%; 48% | 2019-2024

[b]40-50%[/b]
Horace Mann (180): 42%; 6%; 42% | 2023-2025 *** lower bound; missing Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Amherst, Williams; &lt;5 students
Riverdale (116): 46%; 11%; 43% | 2020-2025
Saint Ann's (86): 45%; 13%; 35% | 2024-2025
Chapin (60): 43%; 11%; 38% | 2021-2025

[b]30-40%[/b]
Nightingale (57): 33%; 6%; 28% | 2021-2025

[b]20-30%[/b]
Fieldston (120): 28%; 3%; 24% | 2020-2025
Browning (25): 25%; 3%; 23% | 2021-2025
Regis (130): 25%; 6%; 22% | 2022-2025
Friends Seminary (74): 24%; 5%; 21% | 2021-2025

I wish I saw this 3 years ago when DD did K admissions.  Fit was obviously important (who best to judge fit though than her interviewer who knows the school better than an open house and tour), but this is much more objective than the relative advice we got once we narrowed down (or were narrowed down) on fit.[/quote]

A lot of these numbers are off quite a bit.

HM only lists colleges where "five or more HM graduates" matriculated during 2023 to 2025.  It doesn't list colleges wherein 1-4 HM graduates matriculated.  So the percentage is inaccurate.

Nightingale ivy+wasp percentage should be 23% not 33% (68 kids in five years to ivy+wasp, class size 60).  
many others are off too.  [/quote]

I’m the PP table poster.

Ivy+ = Ivies + Stanford, MIT, Caltech, UChicago, Duke, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, Vanderbilt
WASP = Williams, Amherst, Swarthmore, Pomona
Ivy+WASP = union of those two buckets

For Nightingale 2021-2025, total on their site: 286.

Ivy+ detail:
Ivies = 55
Stanford = 0
MIT = 1
Caltech = 1
UChicago = 2
Duke = 7
Johns Hopkins = 0
Northwestern = 7
Vanderbilt = 7
So Ivy+ = 80 / 286 = 28.0%.

Nightingale WASP detail:
Williams = 5
Amherst = 7
Swarthmore = 1
Pomona = 0
So WASP adds 13.

Therefore Nightingale Ivy+WASP = 80 + 13 = 93 / 286 = 32.5%, rounded to 33%.
HYPSM = Harvard 3 + Yale 9 + Princeton 5 + Stanford 0 + MIT 1 = 18 / 286 = 6.3%, rounded to 6%.

So the Nightingale line is:
Nightingale (57): 33%; 6%; 28% | 2021-2025

I think your 23.8% number might have dropped the “Plus”: Ivies + WASP only = 55 + 13 = 68 / 286 = 23.8%. It excludes MIT, Caltech, UChicago, Duke, Northwestern, Vanderbilt, etc.

For Horace Mann, current lower-bound line is:
Horace Mann (180): 42%; 6%; 42% | 2023-2025
That is 227/539 Ivy+WASP, 33/539 HYPSM, 227/539 Ivy+.

The missing sub-5  schools called out are Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Amherst, Williams. If each had the max possible 4 students:
Ivy+WASP adds 20 → 247/539 = 45.8%, rounded 46%
HYPSM adds 8 from Stanford + MIT → 41/539 = 7.6%, rounded 8%
Ivy+ adds 12 from Stanford + MIT + Caltech → 239/539 = 44.3%, rounded 44%

So Horace Mann max under that assumption is:
Horace Mann (180): 46%; 8%; 44% | 2023-2025 *** upper-bound if Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Amherst, Williams each have 4

Does that address the rest of the “lots” that are off by a bit?
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics