Reply to Hijab/headscarf for Muslims

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "Hijab/headscarf for Muslims"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]If you are all about logic, then it was equally as bad to post a story about a supposed Muslim friend with covered hair and a controlling husband. I countered by another story to show that individual stories are a dime a dozen and prove nothing.  But because HER story fits your cliche, you are bringing up the nonsense of &quot;millions of other women&quot; while my story is dismissed because it doesn't. You have an agenda.

No one has the life they want exactly; that includes you.

It's also impossible to approach &quot;having the lives they want&quot; from an evidence perspective. I mean, what evidence is there that anyone, anywhere can have the life they want? How would you even know what one wants?
[/quote]

Good grief. I didn't post either story.

What is this new logical fallacy? You can't possibly think your bizarre equation makes sense:

1. Nobody has their perfect life ==&gt; 2. it's ok to limit women's choices to home making, esp. if you know happen to know one woman you think is happy with that.

And btw, how did you get from the thread topic, which is DCUM's opinions on hijab, to the above bizarre non sequitur?

Your game is to pick fights on DCUM. It must somehow make you feel better about yourself, and strengthen your resolve, especially when you're so assiduously trying to avoid any discussion of the absence of a Quranic mention of hijab.

I have no interest in helping you with your childish, angry endeavors to find a negative rationale for your hijab. Good bye.

[/quote]
If you didn't post either story, why are you responding?

My equation makes perfect sense.

Poster 1.  Head cover is awful because I know one girl who covers and her life is, like, awful.  Therefore no one should cover.

Me:  Well, I know one woman who covers and her life is awesome. Therefore you should not make generalizations of things you know nothing about.

I didn't post anything about the Quranic mentions and I'm not the OP. Also, I am not Muslim and I don't cover.  Go beat that dead horse somewhere else. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics