Reply to EdTech Transparency

Forum Index » Elementary School-Aged Kids

Reply to "EdTech Transparency "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]A lot of factors have influenced educational technology adoption over the last two decades.  Your complaints aren’t going to overcome most  of these factors.

Curriculum is dictated by state standards, and a lot of states have had some version of “21st century skills” that are tied to technology use across the curriculum. These skills can range from keyboarding, to evaluating the validity of online sources, to learning programming languages.

Another driving factor is book publishing. Increasingly, textbooks are available only as interactive PDFs. Whereas schools used to hang onto hard-cover books for 15 years or more, now they must re-license them every school year.  Also, school libraries are understaffed and under resourced in many districts, so teachers rely on online resources for research projects.

[b]Accommodating learning differences is another significant driver of ed tech. As one example, offering speech-to-text and typing options can be helpful to children with fine motor challenges and language-based learning disabilities that affect spelling. Schools also rely heavily on audiobook programs like Learning Ally to help children with dyslexia and reading comprehension challenges access grade-level curriculum.[/b] There’s also the issue of differentiation. Teachers are expected to provide engaging, accessible lessons to the entire class. Even in private schools where I have taught, ability ranges in classrooms are broad with some children placing below the 10th percentile on standardized tests, while others place at the 99th percentile. As long ago as 2010, I had an administrator tell me “Just put kids on Khan Academy” when I asked him/her how to best accommodate middle school children whose math skills were so weak they didn’t know their addition or multiplication facts. It wasn’t that I didn’t want to use effective direct instruction and help my students. I did have a real time management issue, however, as I tried to prepare kids for pre-algebra and remediate third-grade skills inside of a 45-minute class period with no support from aids or learning specialists.

We’ve  had decades of parent complaints about students inattentive students who refuse to use plan books not knowing the homework and parents not having access to grades. Schools have turned to off-the-shelf software, like Google Classroom and Schoology, to solve these issues. For equity schools then issue devices so that families have access to the online information.

No parent complaint about ed tech is going to do away with the factors that influence teacher and administrator reliance on that technology. Nor are individual public schools in charge of contract negotiations and purchasing decisions. If you have an example of a specific harm from technology, raise it with your school board or private school head. If they hear enough feedback, they may take steps to mitigate the more harmful aspects. But if you think you can complain to the point where your school won’t use laptops or Web-based software any longer, that’s an unreasonable expectation.

[/quote]

....and this resigned attitude is how we'll end up with AI schools as the public school experience[/quote]

+1 [/quote]

[b]Schools are already using it!  We toured more than one elementary school that used AI for kids that needed extra support in reading and math.  They literally got pulled from class, put on a small room with headphones and their AI program, [/b]and done. Schools LOVE EdTech.  Parents complaining isn’t going to move the needle.  It will take a mass exodus of kids from public school, especially the kids who have parents with means/time to supplement with them to make up for the school’s inferior job (and artificially boost the school’s test scores). [/quote]

Wow.  That is shameless.   Are you saying they don’t have special ed teachers anymore?  No aides in the classroom?    [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics