Reply to Getting on GLP-1 after doctor says no

Forum Index » Health and Medicine

Reply to "Getting on GLP-1 after doctor says no"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Seeking out weight loss drugs after your doctor advised against it is disordered. If you truly believe you need these drugs and that your doctor is incompetent, get a second opinion or change doctors. The fact that you posed this question here and the chorus of similarly disordered people are guiding you to their suppliers betrays your and their disorders. This smacks of eating disorders, body dysmorphia as well as addictive behavior.[/quote]

Wanting to be a normal weight is not "disordered" or "body dysmorphia" when your doctor tells you you should be a normal weight and is just unwilling to use available treatments to help a patient achieve recommended goals. A second opinion probably would yield the same exact frustrating result because GPs are not incompetent so much as following their mindset which is old school and basic when it comes to weight management, and aligned with broad recommendations rather than the patient in front of them.[/quote]

I'm a registered dietitian and I see this very often. The issue is the definition of "normal weight." And yes, most often, as I get to know the patient, other factors begin to present that raise the issue of body dysmorphia, disordered eating (past or current), OCD, ADHD and other presentations of disordered thinking.[/quote]

The definition was presented by the doctor who told op she was overweight. It was not in her head. It's not disordered to think that if your doctor tells you you are overweight and need to lose weight you are in fact overweight.[/quote]
+1 Right?!?![/quote]
Being overweight by 10-20 pounds is not the same as being obese or being overweight and having diabetes, high bp, high cholesterol. The doctor told you that you are overweight and should work to lose the weight. She didn't say, "you're fat, good luck with that." Most likely, she recommended a mediterranean or heart smart, plant based diet along with exercise. That's not as easy as jabbing a needle into your stomach and it takes longer, which is why you are recoiling and looking for another means of getting the drug.[/quote]

I'm not the op, but it sounds like you have a lot of bias, condescension and dislike against your own patients if that's the way you phrase things. And it's precisely why women have such a hard time with the topic of weight and doctors. Many people following a meditteranean diet are overweight btw, especially women as they near menopause. I'm willing to bet that if op had a perfect diet and told her doctor that, they'd still tell her she needs to lose those 15lbs. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics