Reply to More skills based grading at madison hs

Forum Index » Fairfax County Public Schools (FCPS)

Reply to "More skills based grading at madison hs"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]You will see SBG spread quickly across FCPS.  Sure they will use the 100 point system for final grade conversion.  Schools will have mostly Bs and Cs but that’s how you achieve equity.

[/quote]

Do you want your child to get a grade they didn't earn? My Madison HS student, junior, just got his report cards and it is all As and one A-. All AP and honors. My guess is his friends did just as well.

He achieved those grades because he learned the material and did the work.
[/quote]

The weird poster is back.[/quote]
Uh, this is my first post on this thread (I think--I guess I  could have posted back in August when it started?).

I am just trying to look at this rationally and as a college professor. My students are expected to do all of their work, graded or not. If they skip non-graded assessments, their overall grade MAY suffer if they don't master a skill before a test or an essay. Or--they may excel on the essay and their grade isn't lowered or elevated by homework that they did or didn't to. Sometimes, they have to make decisions because of time and commitments and that is all part of learning.

I certainly wish students learned this BEFORE getting into my classroom. Right now, many of them think my job is to puff up grades with completion assignments. My job is to teach them the course content.[/quote]

Dear college professor,
  [b]In FCPS, kids don't start getting grades or homework till middle school[/b]. It's hard to understand what a 1-4 grade is in elementary. If kids get a grade on an assignment in elementary, there is only a number at the top or the page or some score that shows up on a website they don't usually look at. Few comments. Mostly experiential learning and no homework. Very few tests in elementary anything worth studying for and preparing for. Most work is on a day-to-day basis or longer group oriented projects done in school. Kids are not taught during this time to do work on their own except in class. By the time kids start high school they have had two years of grading and homework prior in middle and other than high school level classes, these grades do not carry forward into high school. As you can imagine, a lot of middle school students are still getting used to homework and individual work by the end of their middle school years whereas in previous generations, this habit would have been better formed in elementary school. 
  All of a sudden in high school they have seven classes each year that actually have an effect on their future and homework in many classes. Unlike college, this teaching is broad based to give them breath in education and may or may not be something they are interested in pursuing long term. The purpose of high school is not to specialize but to get a broad-based education and to figure out what to specialize in whether in college or another profession. Unlike college in which grades may or may not have an impact on their future, these grades are scrutinized by college admissions, so they do matter to their future. In college, grades are less emphasized compared to the degree a. In college, students also get to pick their classes and have more ownership over them, and they are older so understand that as adults they are completely responsible for their learning. It is not required by the government to attend college and often kids are paying their own way. In high school this isn't the case. With only two years of grading and individual assignments, most kids in FCPS do not know how to manage a complicated high school schedule well. If grading only really matters for assessments which is what ends up happening with skills-based grading, and there is no initiative to do well on practice or for teachers to grade practice, many students without the individual study habits of past generations just don't take the practice work seriously. Add in long classes with block scheduling and computers with all sorts of distractions on them and even the class time isn't taken seriously. With nothing to prep for class, kids come to class unprepared each day waiting to be spoon-fed material. If they have working memory problems, which many of them do, then the assessments penalize them further because they are more comprehensive and since they likely didn't practice as much as if they were graded on practice, their working memory is lower. 
  If the assessments only use whole letter grades rather than incorporating pluses and minuses, then it also discourages students from caring about grades because the discrepancy from one grade to another is so large that the grade starts to feel irrelevant similar to the grading of 1-4. It's hard to measure incremental improvements when the grades differentiate by 20-25% of an assignment. It's also makes it more complex to review an assignment with four grades that aren't very specific than one that is. Do you have four grades for each of your assignments that get graded? There is also no incentive to re-learn material because students are told they can just do better on the next unit despite the next unit teaching different subject material. Retakes are eliminated in place of just replacing the old grade with a new grade per your next assessment making it hard to remember or understand what skills you understand well or incentivize you to go back and relearn the material you missed.
  You yourself are graded on a daily basis by how you conduct your classes and not just the final grades of your students. In life I'm sure your job hinges on both daily duties and large breakthroughs through your own innovative work. Skills based grading does not emphasize daily schoolwork no matter what it says it's supposed to do. Rick Wormeli even has a slide that says that apples at a market only matter, not the cart it comes in as if somehow this product just shows up at the market. The process is not important, just the product. He's part of a long line of educators that were wrongly fed the line that education in America was born out of factory needs and not actually educating the population, and therefore takes a negative view of daily habits that are too "factory-like" to him. Standards based grading of assessments only doesn't teach good study habits which I'm guessing are at the core of your issues since you kids seem to care about their grades and are interested in doing the work, just not making doing work a regular habit. From elementary to high, FCPS is teaching children that daily work and study is not important compared to final assessments and experience. Standards in teaching material have been a part of FCPS for a long time. This grading system is not really about them, but about removing grades for practice work and complicating grading for assessments in an effort we are told to help create some sort of mean of grades for all students to create equity in grading but no real method of how students actually learn more with this system to create equity beyond the grade itself. So, you get a lot of kids in college probably not used to doing daily work and not really understanding how to achieve higher grades and then trying to catch up later.[/quote]

Wow, what the hell are you talking about? Not the case at my kids’ elementary school at all. I had one in AAP and one in gen Ed and both had/have plenty of homework. It was usually math, some LA and studying for any Sci or SS tests. Both of my kids have even had to finish up Art projects from Art class at home. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics