Reply to MacArthur High School

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "MacArthur High School"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]If your kid is black, you should prefer Banneker: the ELA proficiency rate for black students at the two schools is tied, but the math proficiency rate for black students is more than 20 points higher at Banneker (52% to 29%).

But if your kid is white, you should also prefer Banneker: the ELA proficiency rate for white students at the two schools is tied, but the math proficiency rate for white students is almost 20 points higher at Banneker (80% to 63%).

That’s the reason for what 9:19 is calling “skew” in the US News rankings. They’re weighting for demographics to capture the fact that although overall white kids do better than black kids at both schools, and there are more white kids at Walls, [i]both groups do better at Banneker[/i]. Which seems like a relevant consideration, when ranking schools.[/quote]

Weird post.

First, you are just looking at what percentage of kids [i]are at grade level[/i].  Second, why would people only look at test scores based on race and choose a school just based on that factor.  Do you think socioeconomic status doesn't matter?  What about Hispanics, mixed race kids, etc.?  Third, there are only a handful of white kids at Banneker.  Banneker is only 4% white, while Walls is 51% white.  Fourth, while there are a lot more black students at Walls than white students at Banneker, the numbers are still very different at the schools.  Banneker is 70% black while Walls is 23% black.  Fifth, this who exercise seems kind of racist.

Look at the PARCC proficiency numbers for both schools:

Walls

94.35 ELA
54.97 math

Banneker

91.46 ELA
55.43 math

In short, most of the kids at both schools are grade level but Walls is a bit stronger here.  Yea, grade level!

And drill down and look at how many kids received 5s (above grade level):

Walls
61.84 ELA
--- math (numbers suppressed by DCPS)

Banneker
37.01 ELA
3.00 math

Based on this, Walls is way ahead of Banneker in terms of kids performing ELA above grade level and we don't have the data for math (but very few Banneker kids are above grade level in math).

And then, of course, you get the issue that the average SAT score at Walls is way above the average score at Banneker.

The bottom line is that the academics are better at Walls than Banneker.[/quote]

Thank you for breaking it down for us. Good summary. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics