Reply to NOT redshirting an August birthday

Forum Index » Infants, Toddlers, & Preschoolers

Reply to "NOT redshirting an August birthday"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I sent my August bday boy. His best friend is an August bday boy who was held back. They’re all friends. I don’t think any of us have regrets.

When it was time for K, I said to myself - is there any actual reason to hold him back or would I be doing it for competitive reasons?  There was no actual reason to hold him back. I felt he had been there / done that with preschool and would like not gain much from an additional year.

He has a lot of grit, which I attitude to trying to keep up when he was younger but idk - maybe he’s just like that.

YMMV. [/quote]

+1. It doesn’t really matter much in the end. I do feel like the people who redshirted fell into 1 of 2 buckets. First bucket was people did it because even though the child was developmentally ready, they were anxious/insecure/competitive and felt this would give their kid an advantage. Second bucket was people whose kids had some not-yet-fully-understood delays. These kids all ultimately ended up with SN diagnoses of various flavors and while the parents had hoped the extra year would confer “readiness” the kids still had the same challenges a year later and the parents needed to address the needs directly.

My own kids were summer bday preemie twins. They were very academically ready for K and would have been bored with an extra preschool year. One did have mild SNs but he was not the only K kid who couldn’t sit still on the rug for extended periods of time. They’re older now and I don’t have regrets at all. They have a few friends a year older and you can’t really tell the difference. Most of the summer bday kids in our school went on time. [/quote]

The special needs kids make sense but only if you are going to get them help during the year you hold them back.  Ignoring the issues and holding them back isn't going to fix anything, just make them a year older and a year lost in treatment.[/quote]

Except gaining a year of maturity helps a lot. Holding back isn't ignoring at all, in fact its exactly what some kids need. Spending $$$ on crap treatments wastes everyone's time and money. Why ignore the most obvious solution? It's bizarre that you think anything and everything comes before that. You sound disingenuous. [/quote]

I mean, I completely disagree with you. I don’t think children entering kindergarten need any particular level of maturity. And I think kids who have early signs of ADHD or dyslexia or any other SN aren’t going to magically outgrow it by delaying kindergarten. I honestly think everyone should just follow the cut offs. In school systems where the cut offs are firm and parents don’t get to fool around with this, it keeps the age spread of the cohort consistent and better serves everyone involved. [/quote]

The enormous numbers of peer-reviewed studies done that correlate relative age in class to prescription of ADHD drugs demonstrates that you are flat-out wrong here. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics