Reply to Which Dem can win general election in 2020?

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Which Dem can win general election in 2020?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Amy Klobuchar. It has to be someone who acknowledges immigration is a problem, and is willing to do something to fix it. As a moderate Dem, I totally agree that most of the candidates are advocating for functionally open borders, though they're smart enough not to use the term. And it's concerning and not in step with what most of the country wants, clearly.[/quote]

The country is declining in population without counting immigration. We need immigrants to fill the positions vacated by baby boomers. Without immigration US will be stuck with a stagnating or declining economy like much of europe and japan as their population are declining.[/quote]

So we need "breeders" is what you're saying.

[/quote]

Maybe you count you and your family as breeders. Because historically immigrants are more hard working, smart, educated and high achievers. I didn't say let anyone come in. Let us make immigration merit based and welcoming to all people so the country is vibrant. We need to compensate for the the dead weight, entitled native born who won't move to new and better jobs or retrain or educate themselves to compete in knowledge economy. 
[b]
This country is now driven by smart, educated Asian immigrants.[/b] They are the professionals who are creating new companies, doctors, engineers, scientists and innovators. We need more of the same. Maybe they would be role models for the lazy native born Americans.[/quote]

This country is driven by a small group of people that is almost entirely white, male, and native born. Saying otherwise is hilariously wrong. 'Asian immigrants' or immigrants from other regions are here in no small measure due to the immiseration of vast swathes of the native born population (including blacks and other minorities) and the foreign policy/natsec policies, undertaken to serve that small group of mostly white men, that disadvantage many native-born Americans AND force many immigrants to leave their country of birth. Address these concerns and you'll be closer to winning in 2020. Continue on this same line of Democratic Party nonsense, a line that is symbiotic with the anti-immigrant nonsense, and things won't work out nearly so well for the Democrats. [/quote]

Apparently you have never stepped recently into ANY American universities in STEM (a big chuink are asian and immigrant profs and majority students are asians too) or a tech company (many upper management and pretty much at level are asians) . I am not against Asians, I am just telling a simple fact that without Asian immigrants the tech boom would not have happened.

Now the same tech boom is happening in China and India, both of them are attracting more and more VC funds. We should be a country that should get talent by any means possible here AND BUILD AN OPPORTUNITY WALL that they can't cross over and get back to Asia. China is already the leader in Web 2.0, AI and analytics BECAUSE they have data galore and they are harnessing it and learning and improvising much faster than we are.

[/quote]
Apparently, you have poor reading comprehension and poor reasoning skills. I never said anything about STEM or universities.

Simply:
-the U.S. is still run by and for a very small group that's almost entirely white+male. This applies very nearly as much to putatively Democratic interests as it does to putatively Republican ones
-Asian immigration and its high numbers in STEM is mostly the result of policies to serve those white+male interests.

You mindlessly claim the 'tech boom' wouldn't have happened without these immigrants. That's a ridiculously bold claim. What's more interesting is that in spite of this 'tech boom', employment prospects and earnings for STEM workers have declined in recent decades. Those declines were engineered to serve narrow interests, you're just one of those narrow interests' useful idiots.

Also, understand that there are troubling issues within Asian societies that lead to this immigration you mindlessly celebrate. Amartya Kumar Sen and Pankaj Mishra, for example, have long noted that India has policies that offer world-class educations (IITs, etc.) to a privilaged minority so that they can serve as lower-cost labor for Wall Street, Silicon Valley, and other American corporate interest (the small groups of white male interests). That means India marshalls its public resources to produce these people when nearly 30% of its country is illiterate and economically marginal. Hmm.

Since the thread is about the Democrats wining in 2020, I'll end by just noting that the shibboleths you and others recite are often the hindrance to that goal. Work to be more thoughtful, not less thoughtful![/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics