Reply to Be Wary of Racism and Islamophobes

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "Be Wary of Racism and Islamophobes"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]
I am a product of Islamic school. I have family still living in several Muslim countries. Trust me. Almost all children learn Quran in Arabic, in the language it was revealed. And I have said this multiple times, they do learn the meaning of some suras, just not all suras because the Quran is hundreds of pages long. Devout Muslims continue to learn throughout their life. They take tafsir classes or study hadith. There are some who don't. But they should. Allah/God expects it.[/quote]
I thought you thought all hadith is trash? Other than the secret collection under lock and key in Saudi Arabia, yet-unreleased to the world?

I don't believe that an omnipotent, merciful god would make his revelation available exclusively in a language most of his followers don't understand, and then insist that this is the only way it can be understood "properly". This doesn't make any sense.  That's just Arab marketing.[/quote]

Before we engage on this subject of hadith, please find where I said "All hadith is trash." It is believed Islam came to the region where it was needed most. Its okay if you don't believe. I think everybody got that by now. :) [/quote]
I think you - or whoever it was, because this is an anonymous board - are well on record discounting shariah and hadith as valid sources of Islamic faith.  It should be noted that this belief places you firmly outside of the Islamic mainstream, too.

But of course, there's always the secret collection KSA.  Wonder what they are waiting for?[/quote]

I discounted and said ALL hadith are trash? Please show where I said that then. Should be easy enough if I am well on record.

Here is what I did say: That hadith ate not infallible because they are not the word of God. This does not equate to saying ALL hadith are discounted or trash. I said the word of the Quran usurps hadith where they contradict. This does not equate to ALL hadith being discounted or being trash.
I said hadith may not be authentic and there is no English set published that is 100% authentic. This does not equate to saying all hadith should be discounted or trash. I am not starting another 50 pages on where this set is. You'll have to do research that spans beyond DCUM or TV shows about Indonesian children ( if you are the same one who said some of your knowledge comes from a TV show).

This is why these threads take up 50 pages. Please read carefully.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics