Reply to Supreme Court revisits Texas affirmative action in new case

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Supreme Court revisits Texas affirmative action in new case"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]The average black student gets admission to the University of Texas with a score hundreds of points lower than white or Asian students.

Then upon entering the University of Texas, they often flounder. The graduation rate for UT as a whole is 78%, but for black students it is about 60%. And undoubtedly, the black students that do graduate do so with lower grades. Given either the lack of graduation or graduating with poor grades, these black students then face an uncertain career.

How is this good for anybody?[/quote]

Mostly, we do just fine in our careers, given the same access to opportunities that others have (still not a given). I was an "Affirmative Action" baby at a top private university. Though I graduated at the top of my mostly Black high school class and had the 2nd highest  SAT score in that class, I was about 120 points below the average SAT of my university.  Even though the acceptance rates then (20 plus years ago)  weren't as nearly as absurd as they are now, I surely got in with an AA boost (and probably got "points" for coming from my geographical region). My high school science background was woefully inadequate; I had not read novels in my English classes, I had not written research papers; I had not traveled to Europe like a lot of my peers; my father's friends and associates didn't represent an array of professions for me to aspire to or learn about... and none were wealthy.  I struggled for sure and nearly flunked out.  But slowly, with SUPPORT systems (from curiously enough, a number of white female professors),  I did graduate in a field that I was interested in and afforded me some post-graduate options I might not have otherwise had.  For sure I sometimes agonize had a I gone to a "slower paced" school that I might have been better positioned to get into a top graduate program (which I wasn't able to do with my record. Contrary to the notions, AA is not just opening the floodgates wide open). And maybe I could have been positioned for more lucrative positions earlier in my career.  But in the end the experience was good for me in a couple of ways. 1).  The mystery of supposed white (or Asian) supremacy was revealed. I saw what it took to compete in the highest of environments. 2) I got exposed to like-minded students of all races who had struggles similar to my own.  3) I discovered career and life options that I never knew existed.  When I entered the work world, I realized, frankly, how largely mediocre the world is at large (and frankly, how mediocre white men still had the advantage over me, no matter where they went to school or if they went to school at all). I was and am a confident and fearless professional in part because I was thrown into the fire.   What we don't get sometimes, is how such a meager allowance to right past wrongs causes so much rancor amongst detractors.[/quote]

Thank you. It's clear how you see this, it's all about me me me me me me me me me.

What others pointed above--and you completely ignored--is, what happened to the person whose spot you filled? If he or she deserved it more, based on academic scores and/ or socioeconomic background, why did it get to you? Why did YOU exclude HER, just because of her race?

Sorry, but I am not persuaded when college admissions want to play God.[/quote]

"whose spot I filled"?  Sounds a bit entitled doesn't it? Spots in universities aren't owed to any of us.  Why was it her spot any more than mine? It wasn't like my university had said "these are the absolute admission requirements."  Admissions are hardly playing God, they're making imperfect decisions, filling classes against some vision of what the class should look like and using criteria broader than a one-time score on a test to determine acceptance.  The reality is, any white body who didn't get into my university probably got in somewhere else. If they had fortitude and/or access to opportunities (that their white skin might more likely afforded), then they're doing fine.  There is a lot that is imperfect about the execution of AA, but you won't find me shedding tears over whites or Asian being excluded. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics