Reply to Some facts about Holistic Admissions Criteria from Stanford Daily

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Some facts about Holistic Admissions Criteria from Stanford Daily"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]The obsession with test scores and grades as a measure of meritocracy is laughable. What kind of merit do they measure?  They don't aren't even very good predictors of college grades.  (The College Board says all 3 SAT scores plus high school GPA have a correlation coefficient of just 0.48) There are a lot of factors that go into predicting whether a child will thrive at any given institution. There is no reason to privilege SAT and GPA over every other potential measure.

The silliest part of this never ending debate is to compare the US higher education system to India, China, S. Korea, and Japan.  In all those countries, there is an very strong correlation between income and admission to the top schools, even though admission is strictly test-based. Wealthy students are more likely to get in to BeiDa and IIT and Tokyo than into HYP.  And in every one of those countries, the education ministries are deeply concerned that their schools fail to produce innovative thinkers and want to overhaul their systems to reduce academic burdens and reliance on test scores.  Since the vast majority of students are destined to fail in those systems (as defined as admission to a top school), the pressure is enormous and everything besides test taking is tossed aside.

Why in the world should the US imitate higher education system that other countries are trying to make more like ours?

[/quote]

This makes some sense to me.  I think some folks seem to think the US system is based solely on test scores and that would be "merit."  IMO, there is a lot more to merit than perfect test scores.  Any reasonably intelligent kid could get them with the right amount of prep.  The selective schools are looking for more than that.  They want to see passion, leadership, etc.  (and money probably helps).[/quote]

"For the millionth time, this response will address the same issue so pay attention:

Asian Americans do not argue for test scores or gpas to trump over other factors. In fact, colleges can use all the objective and subjective criteria they want to use. That is fine and dandy.

The problem is, pay attention now, the various criteria are APPLIED DIFFERENTLY based on race. Again Asians DO NOT complain about the factors used in college admissions at all. Asians only want them APPLIED CONSISTENTLY without illegal racial discrimination where one race has to show higher test scores, higher gpas, more club activities, more awards, more officer positions, more volunteer hours etc. That is the problem, not that colleges use test scores or gpas. I am sure this will have to be repeated over and over since someone will come back and say exactly the same thing: Why should we only look at SAT scores?, SAT doesn't show creativity, SAT doesn't predict college success, we don't want rote memorization, higher income will boost SAT scores etc. "[/quote]

This is exactly right. The problem is the criteria are being applied different. It is unabashed racism. [b]When colleges are ADDING 150 to 175 points (per the Princeton review) to Black and Hispanic scores because they are Black and Hispanic[/b], colleges are being racist. End of.

There is also the HUGE issue of Caucasian, Indian and Asian students having to work to super-human ideals in order to impress a bunch of admissions counselors who don't work nearly has hard as those they are judging. It's wholly disgusting.[/quote]

NP here. I am an Asian. I know there is reverse racism in college admission, however would like to know if there is any irrefutable evidence for the above statement. If there is why cannot concerned parents band together to bring class action suit? Any Asian lawyers here?

I am tired of living like "second class" citizen in this country working extra hard for every opportunity, that other races can avail much easier because they were treated poorly in the past by certain race.[/quote]

I'm the one who just posted the link.  There is a class-action suit against Harvard. There is also a SC case from a white girl re: U. Texas Austin:  http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/30/us/supreme-court-will-reconsider-affirmative-action-case.html?_r=0

As a white Jewish woman with a white daughter who was systematically shut out of almost every college she applied to (non-Ivys but good schools nonetheless), even with stellar credentials (she is 'unhooked' though), I feel your outrage and completely support you.[/quote]

I'm confused. So whites aren't getting in, Asians aren't getting in and the AA/Hispanic numbers aren't really that high.  So who is getting the spots?[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics