Reply to Is this divorce hypocritical?

Forum Index » Family Relationships

Reply to "Is this divorce hypocritical? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]It means she’s tired of living life like that and is done. I don’t get why you are confused. She doesn’t want to be married to him anymore and be intimate with him. Totally different from your relationship ship with your kid. [/quote]

+1. I'm really confused with the conflation between son and husband's neurodivergence. One is her child. The other is the adult she shares a bed with. I am totally comfortable parenting a child, possibly for life if they need it. This is not why I would or did marry another adult.[/quote]

Because children generally don't prioritize the happiness/contentment/satisfaction of their parents, at least not until they are well into their own adulthood.  Children see the family as a family.  There is a very good chance, even among neurotypical children, but especially of neurodivergent children, that if one family member of the family is disposable (the dad, who has genetic reasons for his condition), then they are as well.  They might think the only reason the neurotypical parent doesn't dispose of them is because legally they can't, and their existence is something the neurotypical parent grudgingly deals with.  They won't feel unconditional level from that parent.  Is it "fair"?  Is it "right"?  Maybe not, but let's not pretend these deep seated emotional wounds don't happen, whether they are "reasonable", or "rational" or not.

Let's analogize.  If kids prioritized their parents' happiness/contentment/romantic satisfaction, then surely they would love stepparents, who from the bio-parent's perspective, are far better partners than the person they divorced.  But no, kids often can't stand stepparents, or at best learn to tolerate them (yes yes I know there are many anecdotes about exceptions where kids loved the stepparents/stepfamily as much as their biofamily, but the trope exists for a reason and many kids even irrationally hate stepparents who do actually love and try their best).[/quote]

I wasn't actually asking for anyone to elaborate on this issue. I pointed out that we parent our children and absorb the effort and sometimes thankless job of it because that is the parenting contract. That is not a marriage contract. OP's sister does not have to resign herself to an unhappy marriage because her husband shares their child's neurodivergence.

Women's lives do not have to be permanently in service to the men around them, as convenient as that would be for many people. [/quote]

Sure. Just don't expect the child to feel the same way. The child will know that he is unworthy himself, just like dad, but that mom didn't kick him out, unlike dad, due to parental obligation. As long as we acknowledge the trade off between mom's happiness and the child's self-esteem, we're in agreement.[/quote]

DP. I think it's absolutely fine for a kid to understand that his mom did not and will not kick him out, because she's his mother and she loves him - but that a romantic partner might kick him out, if he acts like his dad. There's nothing wrong with this message.

Your framing the divorce as mom being selfish assumes that the dad is a safe, loving, and involved presence for the kid, and [b]that's just not likely to be true.[/b] The kid may have no trouble at all understanding the divorce, either right away or as he matures. But even if he is never okay with it, the mom has an obligation as a parent to choose the best living situation for the kid she is raising. [/quote]

There is no evidence from the OP that he is an unsafe parent. That's all projection from other posters posting about other hypothetical ASD parents. "Not pulling his weight" is not a safety issue. Poor socialization, which is what the OP did mention, is not a safety issue. There is also no evidence that the sister is a dynamite parent either.  Yes if he is having severe temper tantrums, he should be kept away. On the other hand, if she is screaming at DH because he sucks at planning or whatever, then she isn't so great either.

There's insufficient information here and the specifics of the situation matter. But the casual ableism against people with ASD is appalling.[/quote]

Even if the father is a loving involved parent, he might not be the supportive loving spouse to her. This isnt ableism against people with ASD, rather that he might not be a good partner due to his ASD traits and refuses to acknowledge them and improve himself to make a better life for his family. Life is hard parenting a SN child, doing that in a lonely unhappy marriage with an unsupportive or difficult spouse, way way worse. There might be emotional neglect or abuse. Infidelity and physical abuse arent the only reasons why someone might seek divorce. You have no idea what others are going through in their lives, no need to make assumptions and judge their life choices. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics