Reply to And Your First Paycheck of the Year is.....

Forum Index » Money and Finances

Reply to "And Your First Paycheck of the Year is....."

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]You're being totally disingenuous.

For three years (two years of the payroll tax, one year with make work pay), payroll taxes have been lower. Now they are higher. You can argue that it was only a "holiday" and you would be right. But it is similarly true that the "holiday" was intended to put more money into people's paychecks so they'd spend more and stimulate the economy. Naturally, people become accustomed to having that additional money. It's been more than 1,000 days now since taxes were at a higher level. So it's understandable that people are surprised and complaining a bit. I can't remember what my paycheck was like 1,000 days either. Can you?"

NP here.  You honestly can say that you didn't think that payroll taxes would go back to their norm?  That's disingenuous  [/quote]

pp here.

as a matter of fact, a reasonable person could easily conclude that a "temporary" tax break would become essentially permanent, as the tax code is filled with examples of this. To wit:

-- All of the business extenders (R&D tax credit)
-- AMT patch (extended temporarily; now made permanent)
-- Bush tax cut rates (not allowed to expire as scheduled in 2010, made permanent for 98% of the population earlier this month)
-- The payroll tax cut itself (extended already once, plenty of discussion that it should be extended again).

It also doesn't change the fact that no one walks around for four years thinking to themselves, "oh, this extra money is nice, but it's only temporary." As a matter of policy, people were urged to CONSUME the extra money in their paychecks, not save it (this was a stimulus measure, after all), so it's PERFECTLY reasonable to acknowledge that people will become accustomed to having that money in their pay and when it's gone, react badly.

Your average worker does not walk around keeping track of tax law effective dates in his or her head. That only happens in Washington.

Moreover, literally millions of people have entered the workforce over the last four years. So, yeah, it feels like a tax increase.

And, for all practical purposes, it's the first tax increase in 20 years.

And I say that as a liberal Democrat who supports higher taxes but understands why some people have their panties in a knot over this and find it repulsive that you would condescend to tell them they should have planned for it. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics