Reply to Transgender Chess Ban

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Transgender Chess Ban"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]NP. I’m not going to wade into the absurd and overblown hysterics in this thread but the reason for this is that the real training advantages in chess start when children are young and when transwomen are still boys. Boys do not compete against girls. For whatever reason (prejudice, cultural bias against girls, earlier spatial brain development in boys, something else), the boys circuit is where there is both much more development and better competition. So, by the time the transwoman has this level of competition, she has been given access to a much larger and more advanced playing field than the female-sexed competitors. They are doing this because they want women to play chess, particularly internationally where women can’t remove hijabs etc., and allowing transwomen to play will stop that. It will also bar a lot of Muslim women from competition, and it is an area where Muslim women can shine and compete.

The people who are claiming this is just bias against trans people quite obviously know literally nothing about chess competition and development and sound profoundly hysterical and ignorant. They also clearly don’t care much or know much about international chess, nor about the conditions faced by women playing chess outside the US. It’s a myopic, US-centric, rather spoiled-sounding viewpoint. [/quote]

wow, if what you are saying is true, then not only trans girls should be allowed to play with girls, but young girls should be allowed to play with young boys. you are stating squarely that the boys' circuits is where the best development and competition is and boys benefit from being exposed to it to the point that a transwoman who trained as a young person in the boys' ciscuit would have an unfair advantage over women who trained in girls' circuits. then eliminate gender divisions in chess. this is not 100 yard sprint or weight lifting, it's a brain game so let's all kids train and compete in the same circuits so they have the same training and if somebody decides to transition to another gender there will be no issues[/quote]

Chess is not divided by gender.  There's a general competition open up to everybody and a separate female only one to try and encourage young girls to play.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics