Reply to Catholic schools gender policy

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "Catholic schools gender policy"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][b]Remember when catholic schools forced left handed kids to write with their right… because of the devil. Same thing.
[/b]
Or priests could not marry interracial couples, same thing.

Or divorced people could not receive communion, same thing.

Or women could not do certain things on the alter during mass, same thing.

or women could not be part of the Dicastery, same thing.

The Catholic Church as it is currently run by the corrupt men in the US is often pathetic and behind the times.

No you can’t discriminate… it’s against the law and against Jesus.[/quote]

No, it's not the "same thing." Not even close. For one thing, most of the items you have listed here affect adults, not still developing and impressionable children.[/quote]

I’m showing you the church is often wrong and eventually gets with reality.

Yes it is similar, forcing left handed people to use their right because they did not believe in science.[/quote]

The church has been wrong about many things through the years, yes of course. But there is nothing in the Bible that specifically states all people should be right-handed. There is, however, very clear instruction that God created us, male and female, each according to His purpose. That is a very different thing.[/quote]

That is sex not gender nor is it gender identity.

Also what about those born Xxy or XYY or intersex.

What does the Bible say about that?[/quote]

Actually, in Deuteronomy (old testament), the Bible does speak about expression of gender identity. Look up Deuteronomy 22:5   And those that are born intersex - you mean the half of one percent that are born with ambiguous genitalia that is almost always surgically corrected to match DNA before the age of 2?  Or those even rarer cases of Klinefelter or Jacobs syndrome, which generally do not present with ambiguous genitalia, thus establishing that the person is male or female?[/quote]

Lol Deuteronomy? “A woman shall not wear a man’s apparel” are we forbidding women to wear pants now? Okay is Green Bay also going to outlaw shrimp?

You think god only cares about 99.9% of his children? You trying to erase their existence? Oh you know people just ignore what god created? Are they not created in gods likeness too?

Xxy and xyy … are all male due to the Y? Really? They all have male genitalia ? Science.[/quote]

Not sure how this elicits a "LOL" - you asked what the Bible says about expression of gender and it is provided. That you don't like what it says is interesting, but not really relevant. And for the 0.1% for whom the intersex issue applies - of course God cares about these children, and they are made in His image like all of us are. However, there is no doubt that this is a birth defect, not unlike being born with, say, a heart issue or being born unable to see or hear. This unfortunately happens in this, our fallen world. We should all be thankful to God and the science He provides that these issues can be corrected.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics