Reply to Did you believe Amanda Knox was guilty?

Forum Index » Off-Topic

Reply to "Did you believe Amanda Knox was guilty?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]After reading the book she wrote on her own, I was convinced of her guilt.

I believe she had a "kinky" sexual side to her & that when Merideth was in her room studying, Amanda, her boyfriend + quite possibly Rudy tried (unsuccessfully) to get her involved in their sexual erotica.

When she refused to participate, I believe the others raped, then viciously killed her so she wouldn't tell anyone about it later.
I think Amanda and Raffael were too stoned to realize what they were doing.

Cannot prove any of this, but this is what my gut believes 100%.[/quote]

Your gut sounds pretty stoned.

She was at her boyfriend's house, likely having pretty typical sex with her new Italian boyfriend. She wasn't close friends with Kercher or the other girls she lived with. She sounds like a naive, trusting American exchange student, so getting attached to a sassy Italian boyfriend and smoking pot with him doesn't seem out of character for that type. I think she called the cops pretty responsibly right out of the gate when something didn't seem right, but because she wasn't there and had no idea what happened, she probably didn't assume that her roommate had been brutally murdered.

I also have no problem believing that the Italian police and lawyers took advantage of her naivete. I don't have a hard time believing that she was slapped during interrogation, that she was questioned for hours in a language she was not proficient in, and that the Italian media, who love a good show, was delighted by the idea of a kinky American college student guilty of an unthinkable crime. I find all that a lot easier to believe than anything you described above, if only because what you described above would leave forensic evidence all over the place, and that wasn't the case.

As for being "too stoned to know what they were doing" it doesn't sound to me like you've ever been stoned. It doesn't induce a fugue state. It doesn't induce psychosis. If they were "too stoned" the likely result was that they had a bunch of stoned sex, watched a movie, and ate too much. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics