Reply to CSrankings how accurate for UMD?

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "CSrankings how accurate for UMD?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]This is the rankings from CSrankings.  How accurate are they for UMD?  According to this, UMD has a top 10 department. I know it is hard to get into and just looking for real world people.  Nothing against US News, Forbes etc.  Something like Computer Science is so different than sociology.

1.Carnegie Mellon University
2.University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
3.University of California, San Diego
4.Georgia Institute of Technology
5.Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6.University of Michigan
7.University of Washington
8.University of California, Berkeley
9.Cornell University
9.University of Maryland, College Park
11.Northeastern University
11.Stanford University
13.Purdue University
14.New York University
14.University of Texas at Austin
16.University of Wisconsin–Madison
17.Princeton University
18.University of Pennsylvania
19.Columbia University
20.University of California, Los Angeles[/quote]

CS prof here. CSranking is strictly about faculty' s research output in particular conferences/journals, not at all related to education quality. In this metric, this ranking is very accurate for UMD. UMD has been a top-10 CS research department and graduate program. All the CS faculty is internationally well known.

[/quote]

Code Signal is a company that provides interview services (coding tests) to other companies hiring employees. I’m sure a new ranking list is a great marketing tool - but this list seems based solely on coding skills and CS study is more than that.

Here we have an actual CS prof - I’m wondering what list you (prof) might think is most accurate?  Or, if none, what is the best way to evaluate a CS undergrad program?

[/quote]
The ranking can also be skewed based on the number of participants.

UMD is a large state school. It takes in way more students with various backgrounds than these small private schools.

If you take the top 50 UMD CS students who took the tests and compared it to the 50 students Brown, for example, what would be the outcome?

SJSU is #2. Are people really going to say that SJSU is a #2 school for CS?  Do most people on this forum even know what SJSU is? I do, because I went there, and I would never say SJSU is a #2 CS school.

UMD has a great reputation for CS for a reason.[/quote]

You are arguing out of both sides.

On the one hand you say UMD takes in kids from various backgrounds and that’s why they don’t perform well with Code Signal.

Then you claim SJSU…which takes in more challenged students by far compared to even UMD…is not #2, when they clearly performed far better than all small privates except MIT.[/quote]
both can be true.

SJSU has a lot of smart kids who probably can't even afford UC schools.  They tend to be kids who live in the SJ area and are 1st gen college students. The school is 36% Asian, and it is not a flagship.  No one would say SJSU is #2 for CS?

Contrast UMD which is a flagship that takes in a lot of kids from various backgrounds all over the state because they don't want just the highest performing Asian kids from MoCo.
[/quote]

Sorry, your explanation for why UMD performs poorly on Code Signal just doesn’t hold up at all.

What’s your next excuse?  I mean it ranks 46…so worse than a dozen other flagships, tons of private schools including schools that almost nobody thinks of for CS like WashU or Vanderbilt…it ranks significantly worse than Stoneybrook.[/quote]

Someones DC didn’t get in and now they are dissing UMD.. [/quote]

UMD was a safety school and of course my kid was accepted.  Such a lazy stupid remark that people for some reason think is witty.[/quote]
You are showing your ignorance.  UMD CS is no ones safety. [/quote]

Yet it was for my kid.  Sorry that in fact for some kids it is pretty much automatic if you have certain stats and accomplishments (including as a HS student winning Bitcamp).[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics