Reply to Road Diets Coming to Fairfax County

Forum Index » Metropolitan DC Local Politics

Reply to "Road Diets Coming to Fairfax County"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]"Road diet": is a ridiculous concept.  Roads were built in the first place to meet a need.  That need did not just go away, allowing road capacity to be reduced without affecting road users.  Adding additional pedestrian/bicycle/scooter capacity is one thing, but it's destructive if done by eliminating existing road capacity at the expense of existing road users who don't/can't use those alternative modes of transportation.  Wishful thinking about green and healthy bicycling doesn't magically create thousands of new daily bicycle riders who happily abandon cars for bicycles for long commutes in bad weather, wearing business attire.    [/quote]

If a road is unsafe, because people drive too fast on it, then a diet can be beneficial even if no alternate capacity is added.

If you preserve intersection capacity, which is usually the real bottleneck, then dropping a lane may not even negatively impact through-flow. Part of this is because each additional lane is less useful than the one before it. People start weaving in and out of traffic, changing lanes and its harder to turn across multi-lane roads. This magnifies conflict points and leads to accidents. Accidents tend to bring roads to complete standstill. Single lane roads have far fewer accidents.

This is why road widening rarely "works." [/quote]

The single minded focus on "safety" also has diminishing returns. Our roads are already quite safe and further reducing fatalities comes at an ever increasing cost in the form of congestion, frustration and a reduced quality of life. It would also be better if our nanny state government just focused on trying to get people around more efficiently and stop attempting (and failing) to micromanage how people drive. [/quote]

Do you actually live in Fairfax county? Outside the beltway in NOVA? If not shut up and go away.

Non biker who f-ing hates the shitty, unsafe, weird combo road highways of outer beltway NOVA. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics