Reply to s/o from the 2.0 discussion, please move if you're that unhappy

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "s/o from the 2.0 discussion, please move if you're that unhappy"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous]I grew up in Eastern Europe and received my K-12 education there. There was no math acceleration outside of a few highly-competitive "gifted centers", but the curriculum overall was more challenging, with an emphasis on intuition, useful shortcuts, and "tricky" problems that required creativity and in-depth understanding instead of repetitive worksheets.

I did not take a calculus class until my freshman year at an American college, but went on to get an advanced degree in math and work in the field now. So you could say I agree with the spirit of the new curriculum: depth over acceleration, building on the basics, etc. But would I want my daughter in 2.0? Hell no! Even though I don't think she has the same natural aptitude for math that I did at her age, nor do I see her choosing it as a profession, I would want her accelerated as much as she can handle. And if that means that I have to spend a few minutes a day at home re-explaining the advanced concepts or making sure that she does not advance to algebra without having mastered fractions, that's ok.

Competitive colleges in this country expect their applicants to have taken advanced math and science classes in high school, whatever their chosen major. One county with a new experimental curriculum is not going to change that. And even if this curriculum became more widespread, it would not alter the colleges' expectations nor significantly decrease the number of kids taking calculus in high school (who may or may not have really mastered algebra.) This is not because some students will somehow magically learn more advanced material while sitting in the same classroom as the kids struggling to add 2 plus 2. It is because some students have parents like me, willing to spend 15 minutes a day so their kid can at least hope to compete for college admissions with the kids of the really crazy parents, the kind of parents who spend an hour a day and hire expensive tutors.

As usual, the students who will really suffer from this will be those bright young people whose parents cannot afford the time and the tutors, i.e. the very population MCPS is supposedly trying to help.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics