Reply to Europe investigating suicidal thoughts with weight loss drugs

Forum Index » Diet, Nutrition & Weight Loss

Reply to "Europe investigating suicidal thoughts with weight loss drugs"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Here's my theory: many overweight and obese people eat to soothe their emotional pain. Take away or diminish appetite and there's no mode of self soothing. Without that comfort, the pain emerges and the suicide ideation begins or they find something else to soothe the pain. See also: gastric surgery patients who become alcoholics.[/quote]

Oh for Pete’s sake. Honestly sometimes I wonder if the people who hate these drugs so much suffer from brain function loss due to caloric deprivation. [/quote]

It’s a valid theory. Just weight loss on its own can cause depression, regardless of the method. Rapid weight loss can change hormones so quickly that it causes mental changes. And it is a thing that people think losing weight is going to solve all of their problems, and when it doesn’t they feel depressed.

That might not be everyone’s experience, obviously, but just because people point out possible problems with the medication doesn’t mean they hate it.[/quote]

NP, and it's a valid theory, and could be concerning. The most successful people I know regarding weightloss and maintenance, are people who've developed a regular exercise regimen - precisely because they've redirected emotional eating with a healthier emotional outlet.

[b]People are obese for only a few reasons. 1) They grew up in families with poor eating habits and don't know better, 2) they're eating to fulfill an emotional need (often unaware). Very, very, very few people are obese because they have a true metabolic disorder. [/b]

If you take a drug for weightloss and don't deal with the mental/emotional stuff (or redirect it with a healthy outlet), it doesn't go away.

And yes, I've personally been on all sides of this coin.
[/quote]
I feel really bad for you. People who pretend to have all the answers are usually sitting on a throne of hot air. [/quote]

It's not a throne of hot air - it's the truth, and I've been obese most of my life.

Why else would someone be obese? I'm not talking an extra 15lbs.

If they really gain weight eating 1500 calories/day, or if they're physically hungry all day long eating that much, then they need to submit their bodies to scientific research, because those are truly incredible human anomalies. 
[/quote]

So much half baked in your thinking. But to start, you can be obese and not be gaining weight….[/quote]

Right, so you're eating enough to maintain your obesity.

But to get there, you still overate.

It doesn't make you a bad person, but those are facts. 
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics