Reply to GDS HS English Classes

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "GDS HS English Classes"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

[/quote]

OP here. Yes that’s junior English and it’s still taught like that. I’m talking about the new senior English in which CRT and intersectionality are the lenses through which literature will be analyzed. This is new since last year.

I went to GDS. This sounds like the 11th grade English course that I took (albeit, this was many years ago), so no, not OP is a troll. That class was very focused on rhetoric and argument in addition to the study of various critical lenses through which literature can be examined. I remember once I had to do a paper that involved taking two of the aforementioned critical lenses and close reading a short story or essay, the goal being that different critical frameworks yield different analyses and interpretations (so, not at all the 'indoctrination', but an encouragement of different thinking). And for the people griping that English needs to focus on the "classics" this same English 11 course started with Greek rhetorical appeals (ethos, logos, pathos) and Aristotle's poetics.

The only reasonable critique of teaching these things that I can fathom is that they're boring and maybe a bit advanced for some students (and I take issue with that claim, personally). English, especially a class which is focused on rhetoric and argument, is absolutely the place to learn about, well, different approaches to reading a text. And I don't remember that DD was taught that one of these approaches is more right than another -- it's simply useful and important to know they exist.

I found this class to be challenging, but it did make me a better writer and I still use what I learned today, as an adult. [/quote][/quote]

So, OP, you're really just talking about one part of one senior English class? Just trying to stir up trouble, aren't you?

My DC found the GDS English teachers to be phenomenal, and he was much better prepared than my public school kids for the writing challenges of college. These are all various lenses through which literature can be analyzed, and what is the problem with your kid learning about them in high school - doesn't that make them better prepared for college?[/quote]

OP here. I'm not trying to stir things up. I find using these frames to teach literature to be complete garbage for a required curriculum course. If you make it an elective, fine. But the class is mandatory for all high school seniors and they are saying these are the frames they will read texts with.

The problem is that the regressive element of GDS refuses to allow any viewpoint but theirs. the english faculty is ground zero for this stuff. I'm all for making optional electives but to mandate this as required curriculum is a complete turn off some kids like mine. And they feel entirely powerless to say a damn thing given the culture of the school.

I've voted liberal my entire life. I actively chose GDS for my kid because of its values. A decade ago it was exactly my speed. Even 5 years ago.  But these last 3 years, GDS has gone extreme. It has.

It's talked about in whispers by many parents. And yet they are all afraid to mention to faculty or to Russell. When one family tried, they were shutdown. I know that for a fact. It's even talked about by some of the older faculty who grumble about it. Some left the school and privately have cited the inability to disagree w/ peers on political views as their number 1 reason to go to other local private schools. that's a wild change from a decade or even 5 years ago at GDS.

I'm not making this up.

The issue here is that there will be a backlash to this. In some of these kids. This environment is and will push more kids to becoming conservatives. Nothing wrong with that but the school refuses to see downstream consequences.  In fact, there was a recent episode of a Vice news program on Showtime just on this backlash from kids in liberal families who went to liberal high schools now opting to become new conservatives - https://www.sho.com/vice/season/3/episode/16/isis-jailbreak-and-right-wing-stars

GDS is just a reflection of the T30 colleges that they aspire to send kids to, I suppose. Except in college, kids can choose electives for topics and frameworks like this. GDS is saying these frameworks are required learning for core curriculum in senior level HS english required class.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics