Reply to Why aren’t art classes pass/fail?

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "Why aren’t art classes pass/fail?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Art, PE and Music elective classes should be pass/fail in high school. There is no reason to grade those classes. Students are required to take them as electives to graduate. Some kids are lucky because they have a natural talent or affinity for one or more of those areas, but for the rest of us, it really sucks to be graded. Better for kids to have exposure to these subjects than resent them because they get graded. However, AP Music Theory, AP Art History etc., are truly academic classes and of course should be graded. [/quote]

Baloney.  My kids are both extremely talented artists.  But they didn't just naturally become talented.  They worked incredibly hard and have put in hundreds and hundreds of hours, have taken classes, etc.  Art should absolutely be graded.  Kids who are good in math aren't just naturally good.  They work dang hard at it.  I'm not saying there isn't some natural gifting in any of these areas.  But it's what you do with it that matters.  PE, music, electives are all the same.  The kids who stand out, who really stand out and earn the A's, they earned those A's.  It's not like they were naturally bestowed with ability that came easy.  They worked hard.  In fact, my daughter has worked so hard in art, as well as many other classes, that she's been offered a spot in Yale's art program.  [/quote]

NP. Some kids are definitely naturally gifted at art, math, whatever. Kids shouldn’t be graded in art for just talent, they should be graded on metrics like applying the concepts they’ve learned, technique, following the assignment, etc.

When I hear arguments like OP’s, it reminds me of kids complaining about learning math. “When will I ever use this?” Art, music, math, history, language: all of it comes together to create a fully-formed, educated adult. It’s all important.[/quote]

Here’s the thing: the teacher is seemingly NOT grading based on following instructions, applying concepts, etc. She is grading based on appearance/art. And that’s not cool. This is based on what she tells students. [/quote]

This is a bad art teacher issue, not an art classes should be pass/fail issue.[/quote]

Disagree.

Gpa matters, and academic colleges shouldn’t care how a kid did in art or pe. College students are not required to take art or pe in college. It’s required in HS. Fine. Then make it pass/fail. [/quote]

You realize studio art is a major at many academic colleges? For the kid who’s on that track, should they make math pass/fail?[/quote]

I'm fine making those classes have a grade but as to the required art/pe/music course it should be P/F.[/quote]

Sorry your kid can’t hack it. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics