Reply to Peer reputation scores US news

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Peer reputation scores US news"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Rearranged the rankings based on reputation scores,  you're welcome:

4.9 Harvard MIT Stanford 
4.8 Princeton Yale 
4.7 Columbia JHU Berkeley 
4.6 UChicago Penn Caltech Cornell 
4.5 Duke Michigan 
4.4 Northwestern Brown Dartmouth UCLA
4.3 Vanderbilt Carnegie Mellon UVA(!) 
4.2 Wash U Emory Notre Dame Georgetown
4.1 Rice [/quote]

The peer reviews are correct.  In terms of academics prestige, which is basically what peer review measures, the above is the correct order.  Academics don’t care about selectivity, they are looking at schools that have the best faculty, facilities, and prowess.  That is why public schools like Berkeley and Michigan are held in such high esteem. [/quote]
I agree but selectivity matters , at least a little, in terms of overall prestige. There's a reason Rice is ranked so high in the real ranking. [/quote]

It really doesn’t matter to be honest. Most of the universities listed above are highly selective because they are small at the undergraduate level. That does not equate to academic prestige with these people.   That’s why Wash U, Emory, ND, Rice, Vanderbilt, etc are not viewed as favorably as the those listed above them. Too many of you are conflated selectivity with academic strength.  [/quote]
All of these schools are academically strong. You trying to make a point but UCLA's 4.4 is realistically no  different than Vandys 4.3 or even Georgetown's 4.2. The difference is small however the selectivity difference between these schools is very big. These factors balance each other out in the rankings. Lastly academic prestige is not over all prestige, it's only one factor of it. [/quote]

These are peer review listings. Sorry if your preferred school is not rated higher.  The point is UCLA is rated higher than tVandy and a Georgetown in this reputation score.  You don’t have to accept it, but according to academe UCLA is a stronger school in this area.[/quote]
Funny when we point out Vandys test scores are almost 200 points higher than UCLAs, y'all say test scores don't matter but when we point out that UCLAs reputation score is only 0.1 higher than Vandys, we should somehow just accept that and relegate Vandy as a "lesser" school. It's silly. [/quote]

The day Vandy’s higher test score taking students teach themselves and issue their own diplomas is when I’ll take your comment seriously.  Joking aside, this is a discussion on peer review reputation scores, nothing more.  Vanderbilt isn’t as highly respected as UCLA in the world of academe.  Just like you would like to brag that Vanderbilt is better than UCLA, because of their overall rating at USNWR.  [/quote]
I wouldn't speak so soon, that Vandy 4.3 might get a bumb next year, you never know. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics